.comment-link {margin-left:.6em;}

Friday, February 28, 2020

 

The Role of Mathematics in Music

The Role of Mathematics in Music*
David R. Couric

Plato.[i]
            What has mathematics to do with music?  As is to be expected, the answer to that question will vary depending on whose perspective is adopted in the process.  On one side of the debate is the 19th century's Eduard Hanslick who, like Tertullian did in the ancient world concerning the relationship of Athens and Jerusalem, answers with an unequivocal Nothing![ii]  But New York Times music critic Edward Rothstein, who this year produced a popular book arguing strongly for a highly metaphysical and platonic analogy between the two "arts" of mathematics and music, thinks mathematics has much indeed to do with music.[iii] 
            Since ancient times mathematics and music have been related in various philosophical formulations, the most famous of which is probably the Pythagorean school.  The impetus for affirming a relation between math and music is usually traced back to Pythagoras and, later, Plato.  One of the first questions to explore about mathematics and music is the fact that the former is usually considered a "science" while the latter is thought of as an "art."  There is a modern distinction or even separation between sciences and arts, with the two having very little to do with each other.
In this sense, science (which term is derived from the Latin scientia meaning "knowledge") would be placed in the philosophical category of "epistemology" while art would naturally fall into "aesthetics."  If philosophy is divided up into the traditional categories of metaphysics (ontology), epistemology, ethics, and aesthetics, then science generally seems to fit more with the first two categories whereas art seems to go with the last two (if ethics and aesthetics are first construed broadly into "axiology," or the study of "values").  The question is whether math can somehow overlap into aesthetics, which seems to be a main point in Rothstein's book.  The mathematician might have the best of both worlds because once the truth of mathematics is seen in its greatest depth, there is supposed to be an astonishing beauty about it as well.[iv]  By interpreting or looking at math in an aesthetic way, there may be a relation of art, and especially music, to mathematics.  So the question of the relation between math and music involves the relation of truth (as in mathematical truth) to beauty (as in musical beauty), ontology/epistemology to axiology/aesthetics, science to art.  It may be that the overlap between traditional categories of philosophy is a good thing if only to avoid too strict a compartmentalization, or separation, of what can be considered a metaphysical whole or unity.  Perhaps math is a key to synthesizing and integrating various disciplines that have tended to become stagnant under the weight of isolation.
            The tendency to separate art entirely from other disciplines, to put it into a category all its own, can lead to an "anything goes" mentality in which there is no such thing as "good" or "bad" art.  Of course, this is the controversy that has gone on for some time in the history of art.  Is it completely subjective?  Can it be objective in any sense at all?  Though Hanslick, for example, was not interested in pursuing any kind of definite relationship between mathematics and music, he was interested in studying the objective art in music, not the subjective response of the observer of art or the composer (or performer or listener) of music.  Hanslick falls into the "formalist" school, which seems to be a reaction against the romanticism of the day and what was known in music philosophy as the "feeling-theory," the idea that music's sole purpose was to arouse emotions in its listeners.  Hanslick believed that music could be analyzed in and of itself, without reference to the audience.  This was an object-oriented view of art or music rather than an artist- or audience-oriented school of thought.  Music, the composition itself, is the object on this view, not the composer, performer, or audience. 
            Another question about art, or music in specific, is whether it communicates anything.  Is the purpose or intention of the artist to communicate feelings through images just as a writer communicates thoughts through words?  The ancient Greeks seem to have thought art was merely imitation, a copy of the real "forms," for Plato.  But perhaps art also expresses something, as Aristotle seemed to think, or maybe it even communicates something definite.  With music, this is an even more difficult question because of one difference between music and most other arts: music can have no reference or object to which it points, at least not in the external world, as can and do arts such as painting or sculpting.[v]
            Where did the traditional association of mathematics and music come from?  Pythagoras is a common answer to that question since he "embodied the earliest human connection between mathematics and music."[vi]  The ancient Greek mathematician and philosopher of music, a contemporary of both Buddha and Confucius about 500 B.C., is credited with connecting numbers and musical sounds and with the discovery that "the pitch of a sound from a plucked string depends on the length of the string and that harmonious sounds are given off by strings, the ratios of whose lengths are simple integer."[vii]  In other words, plucking two strings of equal tension, with one of them being half the size of the other, produced tones exactly an octave apart.  Music manifested mathematical laws, the Pythagoreans discovered.  With the motto "All is number," they believed that music and math held the key to the secret of the universe.[viii]  The idea that the universe displays a "harmony of the spheres," or "music of the spheres," apparently originated with the Pythagoreans although the name Pythagoras is best known for the famous Pythagorean theorem: the sum of the squares of the two small sides of a right triangle equals the square of the hypotenuse of that same triangle.[ix]  Because musical harmony is dependent on mathematical number, for the Pythagoreans, the harmony of the spheres is also a mathematical harmony.  The mathematical harmony is invisible to sense perception, the musical harmony inaudible, according to Dyck.  This Pythagorean correlation of music, math, and astronomy led to the medieval "quadrivium" in the liberal arts: arithmetic, geometry, astronomy, and music -- to which was later added the "trivium" of grammar, logic, and rhetoric in classical education.
            In 1864, music was described as the "mathematics of the senses," and math as the "music of reason," by J.J. Sylvester.  "The soul of each [is] the same!" he wrote.  The musician "feels" mathematics, the mathematician "thinks" music.[x]  Relating mathematics and music is an ancient tradition in western civilization, according to Martin Dyck.[xi]  Many mathematicians also wrote on the subject of music, especially in the earliest of recorded times.  Some of these ancient sources on the subject include Archytas, a Pythagorean who wrote a treatise entitled On Music as well as extensive material on solid geometry.  Hundreds of years later Nicomachus, a first century philosopher and mathematician wrote An Introduction to Music and A Handbook of Harmonics.  He defined math as "absolute quantity" and music as "relative quantity."  Ptolemy, the great astronomer and geographer of ancient times, considered the underlying mathematics of music more important than the role of the ear in musical judgment, as revealed in his Harmonics.  Boethius, the Roman mathematician and author of math books that were used for centuries, also wrote Principles of Music.  From Boethius' to Kepler's time at the end of the medieval period, there is not much information about the relation of music to math.  Kepler, the German astronomer and mathematician, refined the theory of the "music of the spheres" with his recognition that the planets revolve around the sun and produce sounds, depending on velocity.  Father Marin Mersenne, a number theorist, helped popularize "equal temperament," a method of tuning by beats.[xii]  Leibniz conceived of music as "a hidden arithmetic exercise of the human soul."[xiii]  That "musical intervals correspond to simple ratios of numbers" was the idea of Swiss mathematician Leonardi Eulera (Leonard Euler) in a mathematical treatise on music entitled Tentamen novae theoriae musicae ex certissimis principiis dilucide expositae ("A New Theory of Music," 1739), utilizing an analysis of the vibrations of bells and drums.[xiv]  That "all sounds, vocal or instrumental, are completely describable in mathematical terms" was demonstrated by the French mathematician Joseph Fourier.  "He represented sounds by sine and cosine functions whose graphs indicated loudness, pitch, and quality of a musical sound by the amplitude, frequency, and shape of the graph, respectively."[xv]  The physicist and mathematician Helmholtz was the first to give "a physiological explanation of dissonance and other musical phenomena."[xvi]
            According to Edward Lippman, "...the relation of mathematics and music is not a simple one."  In A History of Western Musical Aesthetics, Lippman comments in his chapter "Romantic Aesthetics": "Intrinsically antithetical to feeling, mathematics is nevertheless mysteriously connected with it through the order and system of tones."[xvii]  Lippman divides historical thought on the nature of music into two categories: metaphysical and ethical.  The metaphysical view of music is the Pythagorean "cosmic harmony" conception.  On the objectivity of beauty, Lippman writes in his chapter "Imitation and Expression": "Mathematics...represents the traditional foundation for this view."  He traces the view of objective beauty back to Augustine's view that "every form of beauty is a unity."  The mathematical conception of beauty is "unity in multiplicity and by symmetry, regularity, order, and proportion."[xviii]  Writing on "Formalism," Lippman invokes Kant: "The form of the composition of the sensations -- the harmony and melody -- is mathematical, Kant tells us;..."[xix]  Then, in his chapter "Imitation and Expression," Lippman cites Kant again: "Satisfaction in...mathematical form is the condition of musical beauty, but mathematics has no share, Kant maintains, in the charm and mental movement produced by music."[xx]
            At first glance, Hanslick's position on the role of mathematics in music seems extreme, the extreme opposite of Rothstein's.  However, Hanslick's view might be close to Kant's.  For example, Hanslick makes the statement that "the musically beautiful has nothing to do with mathematics."  But on the same page he also writes: "mathematics provides an indispensable key for the investigation of the physical aspects of musical art..." and "in a musical composition, be it the most beautiful or the ugliest, nothing at all is mathematically worked out."[xxi]  It sounds like Hanslick concedes a crass physical connection between the two disciplines, but certainly not any metaphysical relation.  Like Kant, Hanslick may see mathematics as a necessary condition for sounds but not a sufficient condition for tones.[xxii]
            Rothstein, on the other hand, sees at least four similarities between mathematics and music: both are inductive (induced from the world to the abstract), both concern proportion and ratio, both are poetic or metaphorical, and both "construct timeless forms in a quest for the beautiful and the true."  As he concludes his book, mathematics and music are "mysteries, seeming too close to Truth to be merely human, too close to invention to be divine."  Rothstein employs Plato's (or Socrates') "divided line" metaphor to illustrate the relation of mathematics to music: music is placed alongside math as an element of the "intelligible world," which means both are "images" of something else -- the most real "objects" of all, "forms."  As Rothstein notes, "The systematic life of music and mathematics is contained in this first section of the intelligible realm."  He elaborates, "Mathematicians and musicians may spend most of their time in the mathematical world of hypothesis and reason, but the inner life of their arts is in the world of the Forms, in the processes of dialectic and its argument by metaphor."[xxiii]  Just as there are images of objects in the visible world, so are there images (math and music) of objects (platonic forms) in the intelligible world.  Rather than argument by hypothesis and reason, as practiced by mathematicians in the first section of the intelligible realm, the "inner life" of math, for example, in the second section of the intelligible realm, namely the world of forms, involves argument by dialectic and metaphor.  Rothstein seems to be saying that there is not only a relation between mathematics and music, but that there is also a relation between the way humans know mathematics and music and the way they know the world.  By abstracting from concrete experience, people know mathematics.  And by abstracting during musical experience, people know music.  Rothstein makes an analogy between the method of knowing math and music and the method of knowing things in the external world.  By comparison, by looking for patterns in reality, in the world, human beings come to know something about what is external to them.  Rothstein makes much of metaphor in his comparison of math and music and human cognition.  He says people create metaphors of meaning when listening to music, for example.  The music may not mean anything literally, that is, but it means much to someone who finds metaphorical meaning in a particular piece of music.  That way there is no need for there being only one interpretation that the composer or performer intended.  There can be an unlimited number of interpretations, Rothstein seems to want to say, although it still precludes any insistence that music can mean anything at all, no matter how preposterous or unlikely.
            What, then, is the relation between mathematics and music?  According to Garland and Kahn in Math and Music, the former is more fundamental.  Math underlies music, not the other way around.  They write:
            Music is universal, crosses cultural, historical, and intellectual boundaries, and is grounded in mathematics.  Mathematics is also universal, crosses cultural, historical, and intellectual boundaries, and is reflected in music.  The interconnectedness of math and music pulsates and sings with a rhythm and harmony of its own.[xxiv]
In addition, the authors have this to say in conclusion about the relationship of music to mathematics:
Music always has been, and always will be, a way to express ourselves as part of the pattern that math so aptly describes.  Music gives beauty and another dimension to mathematics by giving life and emotion to the numbers and patterns.[xxv]  
So music, the invisible art, is a "concrete" expression of the abstract description that mathematics provides of the order, symmetry, and simplicity of the universe.  Music reflects in a concrete way what math describes in an abstract symbolic system.  Math describes the patterns found or experienced by human beings in the world, and music is a reflection or way of expressing that experience.  Musical harmony reflects mathematical harmony, which describes the structure of the universe.  Perhaps math is the propositional representation of reality while music is an existential representation of the patterns of reality.  No matter how aesthetic mathematics may be for the true mathematician, it seems that music has the extra existential dimension that will always make it more aesthetic than math could ever be.

           



Endnotes





    [i]The 20th century philosopher Alfred North Whitehead, in Process and Reality, wrote something to the effect that all of western philosophy is simply "a series of footnotes to Plato."  Hyperbole notwithstanding, the history of the philosophy of art certainly owes much to Plato.  Theories of art generally seem to fit into the categories of platonic or non-platonic.  This either-or dichotomy apparently extends to music, too, as perhaps the most important of the arts.  And the platonic influence can even be seen in the debate about the role of mathematics in music.
    [ii] On the Musically Beautiful (1891), Geoffrey Payzant, trans. and ed. (Hackett, 1986), 41.
    [iii] Emblems of Mind: The Inner Life of Music and Mathematics (Times Books/Random House, 1995), 236.
    [iv] University of Michigan's Martin Dyck, Novalis and Mathematics (North Carolina, 1960), in the preface, puts it this way: "...many literary critics and scholars are either not qualified to deal with the subject, or are prejudiced against mathematics, which they vaguely associate with computation and technology.  While mathematics is indeed highly applicable in these fields, most pure mathematicians regard this useful aspect of mathematics as an incidental and accidental feature that does not concern them, just as the literary writer would view the use of his medium of expression in, say, advertising.  Mathematics, on the proper level, is a magnificent web of thought expressed in a subtle net of symbols, affording, if one is willing and able to master it, aesthetic experiences of the same order as those afforded by music and poetry, opening to the imagination vistas as bold and colorful and exciting as in the most Kafkaesque work of literature.  Many prominent literary figures have been aware of the aesthetic and thought-challenging qualities of mathematics.  Novalis was one of them.”
    [v] According to the Academic American Encyclopedia, 662, "Music has been called both the most mathematical and the most abstract of the arts.  Unlike words, pictorial images, or bodily movements, however, musical tones in themselves have no concrete associations, and only gain meaning when they are combined into musical patterns."
    [vi] Trudi Hammel Garland and Charity Vaughan Kahn, Math and Music: Harmonious Connections (Dale Seymour, 1995), 96.
    [vii] Morris Kline, Mathematics in Western Culture (New York, 1947), 287, cited by Dyck, 91.
    [viii] Garland and Kahn, 98.
    [ix] Garland and Kahn, 99.
    [x] "Trilogy," Philos. Transact., CLIV (1864), Part III, 613, as cited by Dyck, 89.
    [xi] Dyck, 89-92.
    [xii] Garland and Kahn, 101-103.
    [xiii] Dyck, 91.
    [xiv] Opera Omnia, Lipsiae et Berolini, 1926, Series tertia, Volumen primum, xv, cited by Dyck, 90.
    [xv] Kline, 287, cited by Dyck, 90.
    [xvi] Lehre von den Tonempfindungen als physiologische Grundlage fur die Theorie der Musik (1862), cited by Dyck, 90.
    [xvii] Lippman, A History of Western Musical Aesthetics (Nebraska, 1992), 204.
    [xviii] Augustine, "On Music," R.C. Taliaferro, trans., The Fathers of the Church IV (New York, 1947), cited by Lippman, 85, 87.
    [xix] Critique of Judgment, J.H. Bernard, trans. (New York, 1951), cited by Lippman, 293.
    [xx] Critik der Urtheilskraft (Berlin, 1790), cited by Lippman, 132.
    [xxi] Hanslick, 41.
    [xxii] Mathematician George Birkhoff cites Hanslick's comment about mathematics having only to do with the physical aspect of music, i.e., acoustics.  In Aesthetic Measure (Harvard, 1933), 204, Birkhoff replies in the first person plural to Hanslick's position: "Our theory is of course devoid of any mathematics except that of mere enumeration; moreover we do not suppose that the elements of order are counted when music is heard, but rather that they are intuitively felt in their aggregate weight."  In other words, Birkhoff seems to side with Hanslick on the relation of mathematics to music.
    [xxiii] Rothstein, 236-42.
    [xxiv] Garland and Kahn, 5.
    [xxv] Garland and Kahn, 137.



Selected Bibliography
"Aesthetics," "Art," "Mathematics," and "Music." Academic American Encyclopedia. Grolier, 1991.
Birkhoff, George D. Aesthetic Measure. Harvard, 1933.
Boorstein, Daniel J. The Creators. Random House, 1992.
Dyck, Martin. Novalis and Mathematics. North Carolina, 1960.
Garland, Trudi Hammel and Charity Vaughan Kahn. Math and          Music: Harmonious Connections. Dale Seymour, 1995.
Goodman, Nelson. Languages of Art. Hackett, 1976.
Hanslick, Eduard. On the Musically Beautiful (1891). Geoffrey          Payzant, trans. and ed. Hackett, 1986.
Holt, Jim. "Roll over, Pythagoras." The New Yorker (June 5, 1995) 71/15: 91-92.
Kivy, Peter. Sound Sentiment. Temple, 1989.
Langer, Suzanne K. Philosophy in a New Key. Harvard, 1967.
Lippman, Edward. A History of Western Musical Aesthetics. Nebraska, 1992.
Nichols, Betty Ruth. "A Study of the Relationship of Music to           Mathematics." A research project presented to the   Graduate         School of Education, Millersville State           College, in partial fulfillment of the requirements for          the Master of Education degree (M.Ed. thesis), 1971.
Nietzsche. The Birth of Tragedy (1872). The Philosophy of     Nietzsche. Clifton P. Fadiman, trans. New York: The      Modern Library, n.d.
Rothstein, Edward. Emblems of Mind. Times Books: Random
            House, 1995.
Schopenhauer, Arthur. "On the Metaphysics of Music." The
            World as Will and Representation II (1844). E.F.J. Payne, trans. Falcon's Wing, 1958.
Scruton, Roger. The Aesthetic Understanding. Methuen, 1983.
Scruton, Roger. Art and Imagination. Methuen, 1974.
Teachout, Terry. "In Harmony." Commentary (June 1995) 99/6:         55-57.


*Written for a UTA doctoral humanities class in 1995.






This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?