.comment-link {margin-left:.6em;}

Thursday, March 05, 2020

 

The Hand of Grace in Jonathan Edwards's Theology


THE HAND OF GRACE IN JONATHAN EDWARDS'S THEOLOGY
by
Dave Couric









Dallas Baptist University
College of Christian Faith and Living
THEO-6303:
Advanced Studies in Historical Theology
Dr. David Fletcher
Fall 1990





            The God that holds you over the pit of hell, much as one holds a spider, or some loathsome insect, over the fire, abhors you, and is dreadfully provoked: his wrath towards you burns like fire; he looks upon you as worthy of nothing else, but to be cast into the fire; he is of purer eyes than to bear to have you in his sight; you are ten thousand times more abominable in his eyes, than the most hateful venomous serpent is in ours. You have offended him infinitely more than ever a stubborn rebel did his prince…[1]                                --Jonathan Edwards (1703-1758)
            Although the quotation makes up less than the first half of one paragraph in the middle of a typical 4,500-word sermon delivered to an obscure New England congregation 250 years ago, the Puritan Jonathan Edwards, Yale graduate and one of the first presidents of Princeton, is probably remembered more by the average American for those few sentences and other parts of "Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God" than anything else. Ironically, Edwards is at the same time known by most students of American literature, high school and college alike, as "America's greatest intellectual," this despite the fact that most would dismiss the substance of his preaching as sadistic, outdated "hell-fire and damnation"-- the ranting and raving of pre-enlightened theology-- and quickly consign him to the place he describes so eloquently. For example, Edwards's work Original Sin has been called "...one of the most revolting books that have ever proceeded from the pen of man."[2] However, at least in Edwards's day, attitudes differed considerably. For instance, in a sermon presented after Edwards's death, he was called "the profoundest reasoner, and the greatest divine, in my opinion, that America has ever produced."[3] Interestingly, "Edwards himself says nothing of the ["Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God"] sermon...."[4] Just as there are two sides to every coin, so might it be said of Edwards: "Edwards is famous, of course, for the imprecatory sermons which were designed mainly to awaken persons to consider the spiritual life, but the delineation of that life occupied Edwards far more."[5] For example, in 1738, he did a series of lectures, a major work entitled Charity and Its Fruits. As a result of the common misconceptions surrounding a proper understanding of Jonathan Edwards and others in his theological camp of early American Puritanism, it is indeed fitting to review his life and line of thinking during the 250th anniversary of the "Great Awakening" of New England. Despite history's verdict otherwise,[6] a thorough and thoughtful examination of Edwards's theology, for the most part, reveals a greater emphasis on God's grace and mercy than on his wrath and judgment; unfortunately, this hand of grace is not usually included in the conclusion drawn by readers of his powerfully graphic images of the reality of sin, righteousness, and judgment such as portrayed in his most famous sermon.          
            What many readers of anthologies of American literature have not done is to take a look at the rest of that very paragraph that the East Windsor, Connecticut, native wrote in "Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God" for an abrupt and marked change of emphasis:
…and yet, it is nothing but his hand that holds you from falling into the fire every moment. It is to be ascribed to nothing else.... And, there is no other reason to be given...but that God's hand has held you up. There is no other reason to be given.... Yea, there is nothing else that is to be given as a reason why you do not this very moment drop down into hell.[7]
Somehow in history, the nuance of "hands" in the title of the sermon must have been changed from the original intention: what the author seems to communicate is not "Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God," but "Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God."  The idea is not of sinners in the hands of an angry God who is about to rip the unrepentant apart. It is that sinners who are condemned already have nothing or no one to thank for not being in hell this very moment except that gracious hand of the one who keeps them from present torment. It is the hand that keeps them out of hell, at least for now! The context is "Sinners in the Hands of an Angry [yet gracious and very patient] God." The picture is of a powerfully holy and just God, but one who has amazing self-control and incredible patience, totally in charge with no weakness at all.
            Admittedly, the Puritan preacher goes on in the next paragraph to imply that the holy fire of the wrath of God is what will consume the "thread" sinners hang by, but they are still explicitly stated to be in the hand of God, the only thing keeping them out of hell:
            O sinner! Consider the fearful danger you are in: it is a great furnace of wrath, a wide and bottomless pit, full of the fire of wrath, that you are held over in the hand of that God whose wrath is provoked and incensed as much against you, as against any of the damned in Hell. You hang by a slender thread, with the flames of divine wrath flashing about it, and ready every moment to singe it, and burn it asunder;...[8]
 Edwards' graphic descriptions of divine wrath, borne of compassion for his congregation, are tempered with grace, providing a delicate balance to a sermon specifically designed for an unconverted audience. Indeed, the second half, which is entitled "Application," begins with "The use of this awful subject is awakening unconverted persons in this congregation."[9] Then, as if to be sure no mistake would be made about the intent of the sermon, Edwards extends a qualification: “Thus all you that never passed under a great change of heart, by the mighty power of the Spirit of God upon your souls; all you that were never born again, and made new creatures, and raised from being dead in sin, to a state of new, and before altogether unexperienced, light and life, are in the hands of an angry God."[10] By no means did Edwards limit himself to evangelistic themes: in September 1739, he preached a sermon on John 1:47, "'Tis  a great thing to be indeed a converted person."[11] In other words, in the former case, his purpose was clearly to present an evangelistic message, and this is understandable since the particular sermon, taken from the text: "Their foot shall slide in due time" (Deuteronomy 32:35), was given at Enfield, Connecticut, on July 8, 1741, about a year after the beginning of the awakening.
            Contrary to popular misunderstanding, Edwards's Enfield sermon, probably the most famous ever delivered in America, did not start the awakening, which lasted for two or three years, resulting in an estimated 50,000 conversions.[12] "According to one tradition, it was not intended that Edwards should preach at the Enfield meetinghouse on July 8, but he stood in as a substitute for another man."[13] In fact, the famous revival began not in Edwards's church at Northampton, Massachusetts, where he was pastor for 23 years, but elsewhere in New England. Edwards simply reaped the benefits of the movement of revival-- first in 1735 and again five years later when George Whitefield came to America-- by forcefully preaching the message of biblical salvation as he saw it in the Bible. Still, in contrast to the oratorical talents of Whitefield, according to one observer, Edwards was "a preacher of low and moderate voice, a natural way of delivery, and without any agitation of body, or anything else in the manner to excite attention, except his habitual and great solemnity, looking and speaking as in the presence of God."[14]
            Consequently, before dying of a smallpox vaccination at age 54, Edwards wrote extensively on revival in New England and has become known as the "theologian of revival" in the history of the Christian church. Following the two periods of revival he witnessed, Edwards wrote Narrative of Surprising Conversions (1735), Five Discourses on the Soul's Eternal Salvation concerning evangelism, Thoughts on Revival (1740), and The Religious Affections. He also did a sermon series called A History of the Work of Redemption.[15] Other writings on revival and the Great Awakening include: The Distinguishing Marks of a Work of the Spirit of God (1741), and An Humble Attempt to promote explicit agreement and visible union of God's people in extraordinary prayer for the revival of religion and the advancement of Christ's kingdom on earth (1748).[16] Also, Edwards is the author of over 1,100 sermons in original manuscript form, many books, 200 letters, and other writings.[17]
            In addition to being the theologian of revival, Edwards has been referred to as "America's greatest [or first systematic] philosopher/theologian," as well as saint, scholar, evangelist, educator, pastor, teacher, missionary, and metaphysician. Four major works of philosophic and polemic theology were written by Edwards after he left Northampton in 1750 following two years of dissension over the issue of church discipline and, more specifically, his not allowing unbelievers to participate in the Lord's Supper. After moving to the village pastorate at Stockbridge among the Indians of West Massachusetts, he wrote The Freedom of the Will, which "alone was enough to establish him as the greatest philosopher-theologian ever to grace the American scene," according to the claim of the late Perry Miller, "influential interpreter of Puritanism."[18] At Stockbridge, Edwards also wrote Original Sin, The Nature of True Virtue, and The End for which God Created the World.[19] At his death, Edwards was working on his uncompleted systematic theology, Rational Account of the Main Doctrines of the Christian Religion Attempted.[20]
            Although Edwards never suggests in the Enfield sermon that God's patience will not run out nor that he will always continue to hold sinners in his hand, the Congregational pastor, who may have had a greater grasp on the grandeur of God's sovereignty and the glory of divine grace than anyone since John Calvin, continuously puts the accent on the hand, the grace, of God. He writes that "God's appointed time is not come"[21] yet he implies that there will come a time when "God will not hold them up in these slippery places any longer...."[22] The bottom line for Edwards remains his thesis: "There is nothing that keeps wicked men at any one moment out of hell, but the mere pleasure of God."[23]
            No less than 14 times, fairly distributed throughout the course of the sermon, Edwards explicitly refers to the "hand of God." Seven times in two consecutive paragraphs,[24] the author mentions the word "restrain" in connection with God's hand on the lives of sinners ("...if  it were not for the restraining hand of God upon them..." and "...if  God should withdraw that restraining power...").[25] In every instance, the point is that God and God alone holds back the inevitable judgment of the unrepentant: "...it  is nothing but the hand of arbitrary mercy, and God's mere will, that holds it [the "sword of divine justice...brandished over their heads..."] back."[26] In the same vein, the Old Testament places the same emphasis on God's restraining power, without which there is no life: "If He should set His heart on it/ If He should gather to Himself His Spirit and His breath/ All flesh would perish together/ And man would return to dust" (Job 34: 14-15, NKJV).
            Just before the application portion of the message, about midway through, Edwards again sums up the thesis of his sermon: "...all  that preserves them every moment is the mere arbitrary will, and uncovenanted, unobliged forbearance, of an incensed God."[27] Edwards then uses the metaphors of a storm and a flood for God's wrath, and it is the "mere, sovereign pleasure" of God that "stays the rough wind" and "holds the waters back...from the flood-gate," which when opened will "rush forth with inconceivable fury" and "come upon you with omnipotent power."[28]
            As is customary, Edwards first paints a picture of impending judgment, then shows the way of escape: grace. For example, following the metaphor of the spider, he returns to the subject of God's wrath. Next, he remarks, "Now God stands ready to pity you; this is a day of mercy" and "God hath had it on his heart to show to angels and men, both how excellent his love is, and also how terrible his wrath is."[29] Finally, "...here you are in the land of the living and in the house of God, and have an opportunity to obtain salvation" and "...a  day wherein Christ has thrown the door of mercy wide open...."[30]
            Appropriately, it has been noted concerning his works, "The sense of fear which Edwards describes was not an irrational hysteria; it was the effect of truth brought home powerfully to the conscience."[31] Moreover, "It should be noted that, for Edwards, profound humiliation before God and spiritual joy go together. A sense of sin and real praise are not opposites: `The saints in glory are so much employed in praise because they are perfect in humility, and have so great a sense of the infinite distance between God and them.'"[32]
            Even though Edwards died what may be considered prematurely, his contribution in life began at an early age with promising signs of intellectual success in areas such as foreign languages and theology. In what has been called "the most important statement he ever wrote about himself," Edwards records the account of what is most likely his own personal conversion, written in his "Personal Narrative" about his life at age 17 when he graduated from Yale: "...that new sense of things," and a "sense of divine things"[33] which were "of  an exceeding different kind from those...that I had when a boy....Those former delights never reached the heart...."[34]
            Edwards, who had written his famous 70 "Resolutions" before his 20th birthday, reveals the kind of mind and heart he had for the Bible by his comments while the young pastor of a Presbyterian church in New York: "I seemed often to see so much light exhibited by every sentence, and such a refreshing food communicated, that I could not get along in reading, often dwelling on one sentence to see the wonders contained in it, and yet almost every sentence seemed to be full of wonders."[35]
            One of the early problems with which Edwards wrestled in his ministry was the notion of a certain pattern in conversion. "Edwards found that, taking the Puritan writings as a whole, they do not reflect an unbiblical stereotyped understanding of conversion...there is no rigid, set pattern within which the Holy Spirit always works."[36] In an early sermon, Edwards makes this statement: "The effect of godly contrition is not always to the same degree, but it is always of the same nature."[37]
            One of Edwards's "Miscellanies," which are a collection filling nine volumes of 1,400 entries of his writings other than sermons, was on holiness, a priority in his early as well as late life.  Of holiness, Edwards writes, "My  heart panted after this--to lie low before God, as in the dust; that I might be nothing, and that God might be ALL,  that I might become as a little child."[38]
            A tutor after graduating from Yale, Edwards was sensitive to the enlightenment thinking coming out of Europe at the time. "His fundamental criticism of the learning of the 18th century was that it failed to recognize the native darkness of the human mind in spiritual things and therefore it placed itself above the revelation of God in Scripture."[39] Although he never swayed from his biblical roots, Edwards was apparently intrigued by the thinking of such as John Locke and Isaac Newton. In fact, it has been debated whether Edwards was the last of the medieval scholastic theologians or the first of the modern American philosophers. Some say both: "Jonathan Edwards was a rational, logical theologian of the medieval sort; he was also something of a Lockean idealist with Newtonian overtones."[40]
            As to the oft-quoted and well-known anecdote that Edwards read his sermons with the manuscript held up to his face, there is a strong case against it, as there is against his reading sermons throughout his whole ministry as some biographers have erroneously supposed: "What probably happened was that Edwards for some twenty years took his full manuscript into the pulpit. He never read it word for word and he gradually became less dependent upon it. Then, for an intermediate period, he continued to write at some length but took only a brief skeleton--`thumb papers' as the East Windsor people called them--into the pulpit with him. Finally he ceased to write in full and prepared only an extended outline."[41]
            Furthermore, "a  whole series of facts which militate against such a supposition" as the one that Sereno Edwards Dwight-- great-grandson who wrote Life of President Edwards-- made in 1829 when he said simply, "Edwards wrote his sermons," has been cited.[42] Some of these facts include: Edwards's grandfather, Solomon Stoddard-- to whom Edwards was assistant pastor for the first three years at Northampton-- argued in print against "reading" preachers; some of Edwards's own recorded thoughts on preaching suggest otherwise; he used a sermon "booklet" of notecard size after he came to Northampton; and--most convincing--"by the time of his death over a third of his surviving sermon manuscripts were outlines rather than the fully written work of earlier years."[43]
            Again, it has been said often that Edwards read the Enfield sermon, but "the nature of the surviving notes for that occasion appear to deny it."[44] That sermon is written as a four-page outline as small as three and an eighth by three and three-fourths inches, on notecards, presumably available for public inspection. "Such skeleton outlines would appear to be pointless unless they were meant for pulpit use."[45]
            Likewise, as to the anecdote that Edwards's sermons were not only read but in a monotone so as not to induce any purely emotional reactions from his congregation, it appears the rumor is unfounded. "What is clear is that the impression made by Edwards as a preacher owed little to the actual manner of his delivery. His voice was low and calm. He aimed to avoid a `sad tone' and the `very ridiculous whining tone' which he heard from some men. `He made but little motion with his head or hands,' observes [Samuel] Hopkins [a 20-year-old ministerial student who stayed with Edwards and his family in 1741]. What was striking was the distinctness and clarity of his thought...together with a seriousness arising from a `solemn consciousness of the presence of God,'" according to Dwight.[46] Hopkins also said that Edwards "had the most universal character of a good preacher of almost any minister in America." The three reasons given are for his "excellence...great care...in composing his sermons,…great acquaintance with divinity, and knowledge of the Bible...spiritual experience. He well knew what was in man, both the saint and sinner," according to Hopkins.[47]
            An additonal anecdote connected with the Enfield sermon concerns the physical manifestations of the congregation frequently cited. However, these "sudden physical collapse[s],...outcries, and...swoonings"[48] were not a common phenomena at the beginning of the Great Awakening. It was not until the time of the Enfield sermon, in June of 1741, that reports of this nature were recorded: "In Edwards' view such evidences of shock were not proof of any saving work of the Spirit: people might indeed be overwhelmed and prostrated by sudden alarm when savingly convicted by God, but he also knew that the same outward effects could accompany feelings prompted by the truth in the unregenerate while under the slavish fear of God. The presence of such phenomena might even be the result of hysteria, yet his own experience in the summer of 1741 led him to believe that in most cases there was no need for friends of the revival to be alarmed if congregations were disturbed by signs of physical distress."[49]
            Moreover, Edwards himself replied to a concerned observer that for most part, these responses to the preaching of the gospel were of God. However, he also cautioned that worshippers should try to restrain themselves as much as possible to avoid sheer emotionalism.
            Even a subject as current as the "lordship salvation" controversy was debated by Edwards, who says, "Wesley's charge is that `Christian' experience is so basically simple that it is needless to attempt distinctions between the real and the false in those who claim to be rejoicing in Christ."[50] Murray on Edwards:
            Instead of being something separable from salvation, holiness is the very purpose of salvation. An argument [non-lordship salvation] which was already gaining ground when Edwards published The Religious Affections has since obtained much wider support: It is the claim that if holiness is made necessary for salvation then the gospel of salvation through simple faith in Christ alone is being undermined....His reply was that, while faith is the means by which we rest on Christ for salvation, it never exists apart from regeneration....Christ's work, and not the work of the Spirit in renewing the sinner, is the sole basis of justification, yet the work of Christ and the work of the Spirit are inseparable parts of salvation.[51]
            It very well could be argued that Edwards throughout his preaching career overstated the case at it pertains to divine wrath and judgment. On the other hand, it may be that any human communication on a subject such as eternal, conscious punishment can only result in understatement. Regardless, a proper understanding of grace, "unmerited favor," must include an explanation of demerit as it applies to individuals. Most likely, by emphasizing wrath first, Edwards was merely attempting to shed light on grace in the end. In that, it should be noted that he followed the example of Christ, who spoke more on hell than practically any other subject, as recorded in the gospels. Jonathan Edwards, whose final sentence on his deathbed was "Trust in God and you need not fear,"[52] may touch a raw nerve for many of his contemporary readers, but sinner and saint alike, in his theology, are still in the hand of God.



    [1] Jonathan Edwards, The Works of Jonathan Edwards, ed. Edward Hickman (1834; repr. Edinburgh/Carlisle: Banner of Truth Trust, 1974) 2:10.
    [2] W.E.H. Lecky, History of the Rise and Influence of the Spirit of Nationalism in Europe (1871) 1:368n, cited by I. Murray, Jonathan Edwards: A New Biography (Edinburgh/Carlisle: Banner of Truth, 1987) xv.
    [3] S. Davies, Sermons on Important Subjects (1824) 4:456-7, cited by Murray, as a farewell sermon at Hanover, Virginia, on July 1, 1759, xv.
    [4] Murray, 169.
    [5] J. Gerstner, Jonathan Edwards: A Mini-Theology (Wheaton: Tyndale, 1987) 85.
    [6] Murray quotes biographer after modern 20th century biographer who almost unanimously fault Edwards for one thing: his commitment to Puritan theology as biblical truth. As Murray explains, modern writers evaluate Edwards from a naturalistic or atheistic world view, although the "modern" view is not so modern after all, since Edwards himself was familiar with the same skepticism of his time.
    [7] Works, 10.
    [8] Ibid.
    [9] Ibid., 9.
    [10] Ibid.
    [11] Gerstner, 128, 18th endnote, seventh chapter.
    [12] Murray, 175-6.
    [13] Ibid., 168.
    [14] Ola Winslow, cited by Murray, 175.
    [15] Works, volume one.
    [16] Ibid., volume two.
    [17] Murray, xxii.
    [18] Gerstner, 9.
    [19] Works, volume one.
    [20] Gerstner, 9.
    [21] Works, 7.
    [22] Ibid.
    [23] Ibid.
    [24] Ibid., 8.
    [25] Ibid.
    [26] Ibid.
    [27] Ibid., 9.
    [28] Ibid.
    [29] Ibid., 10.
    [30] Ibid., 11.
    [31] Murray, 130.
    [32] Ibid., 147.
    [33] Murray, 35.
    [34] Ibid., 37.
    [35] Ibid., cited by Murray, 41.
    [36] Ibid., 48
    [37] Ibid.
    [38] Ibid., 52.
    [39] Ibid., 69.
    [40] Gerstner, 13.
    [41] Murray, 190.
    [42] Ibid., 188.
    [43] Ibid., 189.
    [44] Ibid.
    [45] Ibid., 190.
    [46] Ibid., 191.
    [47] Ibid., cited by Murray.
    [48] Ibid., 217.
    [49] Ibid.
    [50] Ibid., 257.
    [51] Ibid., 261-2.
    [52] Murray, 441.


This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?