Monday, December 13, 2021
Theistic proofs (philosophical arguments), historical and existential arguments, arguments for inspiration, infallibility, and inerrancy
Philosophical arguments:
The ontological argument for the existence of God: The very
possibility of God’s existence implies that God exists.
1. It is possible that a maximally
great being exists.
2. If it is possible that a
maximally great being exists, then a maximally great being exists in some
possible world.
3. If a maximally great being
exists in some possible world, then it exists in every possible world.
4. If a maximally great being
exists in every possible world, then it exists in the actual world.
5. If a maximally great being
exists in the actual world, then a maximally great being exists.
6. Therefore, a maximally great
being exists.
–Plantinga and Craig
Cosmological arguments for God’s existence:
1. The existence of an effect
requiring the concurrent existence and action of an efficient cause implies the
existence and action of that cause.
2. The cosmos as a whole exists.
3. The existence of the cosmos as a
whole is radically contingent (meaning that it needs an efficient cause of its
continuing existence to preserve it in being, and prevent it from being
annihilated, or reduced to nothing).
4. If the cosmos needs an efficient
cause of its continuing existence, then that cause must be a supernatural
being, supernatural in its action, and one the existence of which is uncaused,
in other words, the supreme being, or God.
–Mortimer Adler
God is the best explanation for why
anything at all exists rather than nothing. Leibniz's contingency argument was
summarised by William Lane Craig, as follows:
1. Everything that exists has an
explanation of its existence, either in the necessity of its own nature or in
an external cause.
2. If the universe has an
explanation of its existence, that explanation is God.
3. The universe exists.
4. Therefore, the explanation of
the existence of the universe is God.
Kalam: God is the best explanation
of the origin of the universe.
1. Whatever begins to exist has a
cause.
2. The universe began to exist.
3. Therefore, the universe has a
cause.
–William Lane Craig
1. If something [temporal, contingent, derived, dependent] exists now, something [eternal, necessary, underived, independent] has always existed.
2. Something [temporal] exists.
3. Therefore, something [eternal] has always existed.
–R.C. Sproul
Teleological
argument: God is the best
explanation of the fine-tuning of the universe for intelligent life.
1: The fine-tuning of the universe is due either to necessity, chance, or design.
2: The fine-tuning of the universe is not due to necessity or chance.
3. Therefore, the fine-tuning of the universe is due to design and therefore a designer.
–William Lane Craig
Moral (axiological) argument for God's existence: God is the best
explanation of objective moral values and duties.
1. If God does not exist, then
objective values and duties do not exist.
2. Objective values and duties
exist.
3. Therefore, God exists.
–William Lane Craig
Transcendental (axiological) argument for the existence of
God:
1. There is an objective, transcendent
moral law.
2. Every law has a lawgiver.
3. Therefore, there is an
objective, transcendent lawgiver.
4. The objective, transcendent
lawgiver is God.
– J.
Warner Wallace
Ethical
argument:
1. If God (good) does not exist,
evil does not exist.
2. Evil exists.
3. Therefore, God (good) exists.
–DRC
Mathematical
argument for God's existence:
1. If God does not exist, the
applicability of mathematics to the physical world is just a happy coincidence.
2. The applicability of mathematics
to the physical world is not just a happy coincidence.
3. Therefore, God exists.
–William Lane Craig
Logical
and mathematical argument for
God’s existence and against naturalism:
1. If God does not exist, and
naturalism is true, then the laws of logic and mathematics were invented.
2. The laws of logic and
mathematics were discovered.
3. Therefore, God exists, and
naturalism is false.
–DRC
Arguments for the supernatural and
against naturalism:
1. If the supernatural does not
exist, and naturalism is true, then nature is not temporal but eternal.
2. Nature is not eternal
(supernature).
3. Therefore, the supernatural
exists, and naturalism is false.
–DRC
1. If the supernatural does not
exist, and naturalism is true, then the natural has no necessary condition.
2. The natural has a necessary
condition, namely the supernatural.
3. Therefore, the supernatural
exists, and naturalism is false.
OR
1. The supernatural is a necessary
but not sufficient condition for the natural (if the natural exists, then the
supernatural must exist).
2. The natural is a sufficient
condition for the supernatural (the natural and the supernatural exist).
3. Therefore, the supernatural
exists.
–DRC
Historical argument for the existence of God from the resurrection of Jesus:
1. Three established facts
concerning the fate of Jesus [accepted by most historians, including secular]
are his empty tomb, his postmortem appearances, and his disciples’ belief in
his resurrection.
2. The hypothesis “God raised Jesus
from the dead” is the best explanation of these facts.
3. The hypothesis “God raised Jesus
from the dead” entails that the God revealed by Jesus exists.
4. Therefore, the God revealed by Jesus exists.
–William Lane Craig
Existential argument from the immediate experience of God [for knowing as opposed to showing that the biblical God exists or that Christianity is true apart from argumentation]:
1. Beliefs which are appropriately
grounded [on the inner witness of the Holy Spirit] may be rationally accepted
as basic beliefs not grounded on argument.
2. Belief that the biblical God
exists is appropriately grounded [on the Holy Spirit].
3. Therefore, belief that the biblical God exists may be rationally accepted as a basic belief not grounded on argument.
–William Lane Craig
[Existential argument from] The Immediate Experience of God [for knowing that the biblical God exists or that Christianity is true apart from argumentation]:
1. Beliefs which are appropriately grounded [on the witness of the Holy Spirit*] may be rationally accepted as basic beliefs not grounded on argument
2. Belief that the biblical God exists is appropriately grounded [on the Holy Spirit]
Therefore,
3. Belief that the biblical God exists may be rationally accepted as a basic belief not grounded on argument
–William Lane Craig
*Romans 8:16, testimonium spiritus
sancti internum (internal testimony, or inner witness [special illumination],
of the Holy Spirit)
The Spirit’s Internal Witness
https://www.ligonier.org/learn/articles/spirits-internal-witness/
–R.C. Sproul
Arguments for inspiration, infallibility, and inerrancy:
Argument for the infallibility [and therefore inerrancy] of the biblical scriptures:
1. The Bible is a basically reliable and generally trustworthy historical document.
2. On the
basis of this document, there is sufficient evidence to believe that Jesus is
the Son of God.
3. Jesus
being the Son of God is an infallible authority.
4. Jesus
teaches that the Bible is more than basically reliable and generally trustworthy; it is
the very Word of God.
5. The Word
that comes from God is utterly trustworthy because God is utterly trustworthy.
6.
Therefore, on the basis of the infallible authority of Jesus, the Bible is
utterly trustworthy, i.e., infallible.
–R.C.
Sproul (1978)
1. If the Bible is infallible, then it's inerrant.
2. The Bible is infallible (see above).
3. Therefore it's inerrant.
Arguments for inspiration, infallibility, and/or inerrancy:
1.
Whatever God teaches is true.
2.
Historical, prophetic, and other evidences show that Jesus is God.
3.
Therefore, whatever Jesus teaches is true.
4.
Jesus taught that the Scriptures are the word of God.
5.
Therefore, the Scriptures are the word of God.
– Kenneth Kantzer
1.
Whatever God teaches is true.
2.
Historical, prophetic, and other evidences show that Jesus is God.
3.
Therefore, whatever Jesus teaches is true.
4.
Whatever Jesus teaches is true.
5.
Jesus taught that the Scriptures are the inspired, infallible, inerrant word of God.
6.
Therefore, the Scriptures are the inspired, infallible, inerrant word of God.
– Kenneth Kantzer
As Friedrich Schleiermacher once put it, “We do not believe in Christ because we believe in the Bible; we believe in the Bible because we believe in Christ.”
The Bible is the word of God not just because the word of God says so but because the Son of God said so, according to Norman Geisler.
The personal word of God is impeccable; the propositional word of God is impeccable. Jesus is infallible, cannot sin, and therefore “inerrant,” does not sin, likewise scripture, truly divine and truly human. One person, two natures. One book, two natures.
When he said the Bible is the word of God not just because the word of God says so but because the Son of God said so, Norman Geisler was obviously answering the second, apologetical, question. As Friedrich Schleiermacher also correctly characterized it Christologically, “We do not believe in Christ because we believe in the Bible; we believe in the Bible because we believe in Christ.”
https://www.reasonablefaith.org/writings/question-answer/grounds-for-belief-in-biblical-inspiration
However, it appears that there are two ways to answer the apologetical question of whether the Bible’s own claim to inspiration is true, on the grounds of the “inward work of the Holy Spirit bearing witness by and with the Word in our hearts” (Westminster Confession 1.5) and/or on the grounds of a sound inductive argument for scriptural inspiration:
1. God
exists.
2. God
raised Jesus from the dead.
3. If God
raised Jesus from the dead, God ratified Jesus’s teachings.
4. Jesus’s
teachings were such that they could be plausibly interpreted to imply the
inspiration of Old and New Testament Scriptures.
–William Lane Craig
Epistemological argument on the separability of divine foreknowledge and foreordination:
1. Necessarily, if God foreknows X, then X will happen.
2. God foreknows X.
3. Therefore, X will happen (but not necessarily).
-WLC
