Friday, August 21, 2020
Where There's a Will, There's Rhetoric
Dave Couric
HUMA 5301: Foundations of Rhetoric (Dr.
Kellner, UTA)
Paper 3: Where There's a Will, There's
Rhetoric
April 12, 1994
The "continuing
hostility" between philosophy and rhetoric that has gone on throughout
history, John S. Nelson points out in the concluding chapter of The Rhetoric
of the Human Sciences ("Seven Rhetorics of Inquiry: A
Provocation," 413), is really between philosophers and the rhetoricians.
That is, though philosophy apparently won the day from the ancient period to
the modern, rhetoric has made inroads and gained ground with a large segment of
philosophy in the postmodern era. The reason this has happened is that
philosophy, broadly speaking, has split into two camps in the 20th century.
Nelson therefore pinpoints "the more specific opponent" of rhetoric
as "logic of inquiry, in the singular and relentlessly abstracting style
that loses the reality and substance of research," rather than philosophy
as a whole. For he further states, "Indeed, renewed recognition
that rhetoric is epistemic owes much to the work of some recent philosophers." What
appears to be the case is that half of philosophy has defected and joined the
rhetorical ranks so that it is no longer a strict "us vs. them"
situation with all the philosophers on one side and the rhetors on the other.
Instead of philosophy in
general being the enemy of rhetoric, Nelson says logic in particular is the
culprit. Since contemporary philosophy is generally divided into the
"analytic" and "continental" schools, it is obviously the
analytic philosophers that see "logic or some equivalent" as the
ground of epistemology. So the continental, or existential, philosophers are
the only ones who have recognized rhetoric as "epistemic," i.e.,
creating knowledge rather than simply describing it. Nelson seems to
have this latter group of philosophers in mind when he writes of the
pluralization, or diversification, of logic of inquiry into logic, or rhetorics,
of inquiry. In this sense, the same distinction could also be made
between modern philosophy (analytic, for the most part) and postmodern
philosophy (extension of continental).
How the distinction between
modern and postmodern thought, or analytic and continental, explains the
complex relationship between philosophy and rhetoric in general may be better
understood in light of the history of thought itself. It must be
kept in mind that in the broadest of terms philosophy itself has been
fragmented all along into two basic sides. On the one hand have been
those who emphasize the rational over the empirical, e.g., Parmenides, Plato,
Augustine, and Descartes. On the other hand, there have been those responding
with an emphasis primarily on the empirical, e.g., Heraclitus, Aristotle,
Aquinas, and Hume. Then there was Kant, who attempted to synthesize
the two sides. Whether Kant was successful or not, there is no doubt
that his intention was to take a both/and approach to the two main schools of
thought down through history to his time. What seems to have
happened is that the analytic school today is the descendant of
Kant. This is modernism, the enlightenment view of science, that
reason and empirical experience alone can solve all the world's problems.
Those who have eschewed
Kant (at least in particular areas), however, tend to be in the continental
school, which spawned postmodernism, hence the major influence of French
thinkers like Derrida and others of his ilk. This group has to a
large extent rejected reason and empirical science both, thus placing
themselves in an existential position that embraces rhetoric as a
"foundation." Since reason or experience is no longer the foundation
as it is for modernists, the postmodernists are actually characterized as
"anti-foundationalists." Rhetoric, though, is the ground
of postmodern epistemology, according to Nelson.
So the history of thought
indicates that two conflicts were going on at the same time, one within
philosophy itself all the way up to present day analytic and continental
schools, and another between philosophy in general and rhetoric. The complexity
comes in when philosophy comes together and then splits again after Kant. At
that point, it seems that a large part of philosophy is opened up to the
concerns of rhetoric for the first time in history. Now the conflict
between philosophy and rhetoric is really between philosophy and
rhetoric. The modern split within philosophy, then, has led to a
rapprochement with rhetoric.
If the conflict between philosophy and rhetoric is traced back to antiquity, it might be noticed that in general philosophers then were more concerned with the intellect, proof, and theory than the rhetors, who tended to emphasize the will, persuasion, and practical application. This can be seen in the relationship of Plato to Gorgias, for example. Indeed, until Kant it seems that most of philosophy concerned itself with matters of the intellect (and sense perception). It was not until after Kant that philosophy, or part of it at least, turned more to matters of the human will, hence Nietzsche's famous "will to power" concept and existentialism's emphasis on the "autonomous" will. Of course, the analytic school went the other direction, away from the continental move to the will. The analytics kept the emphasis on the intellect and senses, the rational and empirical. In this way, it is easy to see with which side rhetoric would have the most in common. Rhetoric has traditionally been considered the "icing on the cake," which persuades. Philosophy, aligned more with logic, was always the "cake," which proves. The latter was seen as objective and universal while the former was subjective and particular. That is why throughout history philosophy has generally been perceived in a more positive way than rhetoric. Like it or not, the accent has usually been more on what is objective and universal than not. So that context naturally would have created a climate of treating rhetoric as the proverbial stepchild. This dichotomization of two dimensions of reality seems to be the crux of the problem.
All but perhaps some die-hard
analytics would agree that philosophy and rhetoric should be integrated in a
complementary fashion. What both sides disagree on is how to strike
the proper balance in doing so. To the extent that philosophy
historically has denied rhetoric any place at all, that is, ignored the
dimension of the human will altogether, this is clearly wrong-headed. This
seems to have been the case in general though some philosophers from ancient
times, Augustine e.g., did give rhetoric and the will more attention than
others. The same goes for those analytic philosophers today, who see
no influence of rhetoric or the will in science, for example. This
is certainly an extreme. But the other extreme is just as much of a problem if
not more. If the rhetoricians want to crucify the intellect in favor
of the will alone, as a flat rejection of reason and empirical experience, this
is also going too far. The same goes for the continental philosophers
who make the will so superior to the intellect and senses that an ambiguous
mysticism is almost the result. Kant's both/and has become an
either-or again, only this time the two choices are between the intellect and
the will instead of the intellect and the senses. That may be
because he failed to achieve the synthesis after all. But that does
not mean the both/and approach is wholly mistaken.
Instead of an intellectual vs. sensible either-or dilemma (rational vs. empirical) that preceded Kant, what now appears to be the situation is an even broader intellectual vs. volitional either-or dilemma, represented by the one school of philosophy (analytic) vs. rhetoric (and the other philosophical school, continental). As an illustration, this is like a disagreement between "left-brainers" (analytic) and "right-brainers" (existential), or even more to the point between the left side and right side of the same brain. The point is that the brain comes with two sides, so pitting one against the other is futile. They work together, or at least are supposed to be complementary. So it is with the human being. By whatever name (soul/spirit, the dimensions of thought and action are both human. People think and act, even if the two cannot be separated. There is an intellectual dimension as well as volitional dimension, the intellect and the will, which may be different aspects of the same thing (the emotions would also have to be analyzed in a related realm).
The either-or fallacy is
that either philosophy alone is right and there is no room at all for rhetoric
(except perhaps as "ornamental"), or that rhetoric alone is right and
there is no room at all for philosophy (of any nonrhetorical
variety). It is not that simple, or simplistic. There is
a possible synthesis: the integration of the intellect and will into a
complementary whole, as it is in human beings. Postmodernism and the
continental philosophers seem to overemphasize the will to the exclusion of the
intellect as a reaction to modernism and the analytic philosophers do the
opposite by ignoring the will. So there are still two conflicts,
both within philosophy and between philosophy and rhetoric, that seem to be an
over-reaction to the opposition. When will someone come along and really be in
the middle, affirming the whole human being?
