Sunday, December 05, 2021
What I Do in the Writing Center
What I Do in the Writing Center: Reflections
on a Long Career in College Tutoring (2021)
“I can’t be a tutor,” my wife says,
“because I would just correct the student’s paper.” Working around tutors, but
not as a tutor, at a college for many years has taught her a valuable lesson in
tutoring: Don’t just correct a student’s work because that’s not going to help
the student in the long term. In what is called “best practices,” minimalism in
tutoring is the way to go. Do as little as possible and still help the
students. It’s counterintuitive and very difficult to do consistently day in
and day out. But a good tutor must be committed to minimalism in some sense and
in general. Of course there are some exceptions to the general rule, but
finding creative ways of prompting students to do it on their own with as much
of a hands-off approach as possible will result in student success over the
long run. Sometimes, though, some students need not only to be told something
but also to be shown exactly how to do something. The bottom line is that
tutoring must be student-centric, just as a business must be customer-centric.
Many times over the years students
have stopped me and asked point blank, “Do you teach?” Or they say, “You should
do this as a teacher” or something to that effect. My reply will always contain
the lesson on the distinction between teaching and tutoring. I try to make it
clear to them by giving the illustration of a doctor and patients. No one would
ask a doctor why she or he doesn’t see groups of patients at a time. It must be
one at a time because each individual has specific needs that have to be
diagnosed separately and then each given a prescription accordingly. It’s the
same with a tutor.
First, when I sit down with a
typical student in the writing center to help review a paper, I often start by
observing issues of formatting style, which usually ends with showing how to
make sure the bibliographic source page and in-text or parenthetical citations
properly relate.
Second, I discuss issues of
organizing ideas with the student, which most of the time means determining
whether the topic sentences relate to the thesis sentence properly or need
revising.
Third, I address issues involved in
properly editing grammar, which usually means looking for the most common error
of all, the ubiquitous comma splice, among a few other usual suspects in the
editing process.
Following best practices in writing
tutoring requires starting with higher-order things, organizing ideas and
content, rather than lower-order things, formatting style and editing grammar. That’s
not always possible, but generally it’s a good idea. The only reason I switch
it around and start with format and then go to organization is that a paper
sort of presents itself in that order. When I first look at a student’s paper,
the first thing I notice is whether the overall appearance conforms to the
standard format required. Some things stand out when they’re off and need to be
attended to. But there are other times when the first thing is to begin with
the thesis sentence and how to formulate it based on the teacher’s prompt, or
instructions. In a way, the process is the reverse of how students used to
learn the classical trivium of grammar, logic, and rhetoric, in that order,
starting in elementary school. Classical education moved from lower order to
higher order. Tutoring attempts to reverse the order in reviewing a student’s
writing. To be sure, there are many times when there’s overlap between the
orders and so more than one is addressed at one time, or in a back and forth
manner.
If education were done as it was
classically, there would be less need to dwell on lower-order issues. That’s
not where tutors find themselves in the modern world. About the time elementary
schools were no longer called grammar schools, many years ago, the teaching of
grammar to primary-school students declined. So many students must make up for
that loss in the first year of college, and that’s one of the job descriptions
of tutors. Just as math students simply cannot move up to algebra without
mastering arithmetic, so writing (rhetoric) students are missing something
foundational without first mastering grammar and logic because grammar is the
arithmetic of writing.
As a new tutor in the late 1980s, I
realized fairly quickly that I needed to come up with a way to help students
with editing their grammar in a way that would fall far short of simply telling
them what was wrong and how to correct it or, worse, taking their paper in hand
and making corrections on it with a red pen. The main thing I noticed when
reviewing their papers was that something was often missing, namely,
punctuation, letters, or words.
Reflecting on that led to the idea
of marking up the paper in a way that would indicate where the missing items
were, and maybe what kinds of errors, but wouldn’t indicate what the specific
corrections were. So I devised a three-mark system of circles, underlines, and
insertion carets and developed a markup key showing the meaning of each so that
a student could use the key to correct a paper that I had marked up. While this
didn’t cover every last aspect of grammar, it did seem to catch about ninety
percent.
First, if I put a blank circle in a
particular place, that meant a punctuation mark was missing. If the circle was
around a punctuation mark, then it meant wrong punctuation. A third function of
the circle was to indicate the wrong vocabulary word used.
Second, if I underlined a word, that
meant a letter or letters were missing. The underline mark was also used to
indicate the wrong word form, such as in subject-verb agreement or verb tense.
Third, if I placed a caret
(upside-down V) between two words, that meant a word or words were missing at
that particular place.
The main point was to get the
students to focus only on the places where something was missing so they could
get to the point where they eventually would prevent important things like
letters and words from mysteriously dropping out of their writing in some sort
of mind-hand disconnection. Many a student has pushed back (to no avail) when I
handed the paper over for corrections to be made by the writer rather than the tutor.
Once they got the hang of it and were willing to at least guess instead of
leaving “blanks,” I would estimate that they were right in their corrections on
average more than half the time, maybe even three-fourths of the time. That
would leave just a few markups that we needed to discuss.
Now, many years later in a
post-pandemic world, I’m adapting the same markup system to a digital context,
which only requires a little adjusting. Instead of using handwritten circles,
underlines, and carets, in MS Word, I can highlight a spot between words and
put a comment about the missing punctuation, or I can highlight wrong
punctuation and put that in the comment off to the side. Highlighting whole
words can be used for missing letters and wrong word forms. Highlighting
between words can be used for missing words, and highlighting whole words can
be used for wrong vocabulary words. Not only is the digital world simpler in
some ways but also, with online Word, a student can begin correcting mistakes
within the same document at the same time as I am marking it up, in a race to
the finish.
In a sense, what I do is best summed
up by a motto that the Mountain View student activities office used for many
years: "Empowering students for success, one life at a time," which I
think should have been and is the tutoring mission statement in a nutshell.*
The greatest compliment I ever received from a student came just recently when
a student had a unique answer to her own question of why she was in the writing
center that day. She mentioned after a first consultation that she now knew why
she was sent to me to get help. I took the bait and asked directly, “So why is
that?” I had never heard the answer she gave, in all my years of experience in
the field: “Because you love what you do.”
What do I do in the writing center?
I pour my heart and soul into it, into the students. When I review a student’s written work, I try to check three
aspects for state of completion: organizing ideas, formatting style, and
editing grammar. But the mission isn’t complete unless, in doing so, I find a
way to empower the student for future success.
David R. Couric (couric@dcccd.edu)
is retired from Dallas College, Mountain View, with 34 years of experience in
the higher-education field there, including a decade in the Ink Spot Academic
Center for Writing (2011-21); he still works part time as an academic coach
(writing tutor) in the Learning Commons.
* For example, Camila Ramos (3:52,
4:09, 6:02): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6Gzn4F0SUuE&list=FL6YD9yIeau9YFtUjjlL2JEQ&index=4
For another example, Lizeth Moyao:
https://www.linkedin.com/feed/update/urn:li:activity:7331464962139230209/
Axis: The Blog
What I Do in the Writing Center: A First-Person Account of a Long Career in College Tutoring
March 29, 2023
The Lion's Pride, Mountain View College newspaper (2017):
David Couric Plans to Retire after Decades of Helping Students
https://acrobat.adobe.com/link/review?uri=urn:aaid:scds:US:529106cc-6de4-34da-96d8-e7907ec3c4a5
The Lion's Pride, Mountain View College newspaper (2014):
The Ink Spot-Light: David Couric
https://acrobat.adobe.com/link/review?uri=urn:aaid:scds:US:079624f0-1478-3e02-af4e-70b5a3a22d2d
Back to main page: Memorable Memories: One Son's Memoirs of Life in the Robert Adams Couric (1929-2011) Family
