
It’s late 1975, or maybe the early days of
’76, and I’ve been upstairs “in my room,” to borrow a Beach Boys song title,
every day for a week going on two, reading through the whole New Testament part
of the Bible for hours on end, sometime during the Christmas holidays in our
Everman, Texas, family home. I’m reading every word, hanging on every word, and
experiencing the shock of my life: It’s as if I’m reading truth after truth
about myself for the first time. I can’t believe I’ve never seen this stuff before.
Bible reading me/Scripture interpreting my experiences (1)
The Bible is really reading me rather than
the other way around, Scripture interpreting my own life experiences one by
one. It, the Bible, seems to know everything about me. Verse after verse, I
think: “That’s exactly right. That’s how it is in my life. How does the Bible
know me so well?” I am amazed time and again that the New Testament describes
my inner self, feelings, thoughts, and ideas so accurately, with the words
seeming to leap off the pages right at me as if to grab me by the throat or the
shoulders and shake me with the message “Are you listening? Do you hear this?”
It’s my 1969 Revised Standard Version Bible that I’m highlighting fervently in
light blue, probably the only modern version available when my parents gave one
to each of their four children for Christmas that year, still a
treasured Bible for me to this day. Known as “the Christian Carole King,” Janny
Grein has a song out at the time, “Covenant Woman,” which describes my
encounter with the New Testament perfectly: “Word came to life, came to me,” or
as Michael W. Smith would later write in “Breathe”: “Your very word spoken to
me.” As this is happening to me, as I'm drinking the living water offered on its pages, I know the Bible is true, and since that time
more than forty years ago, I’ve never doubted that one proposition: The Bible is
truth; it’s the very Word of God. Looking back on those things now, I see that
Jesus is also the very Word (logos) of God such that the common factor
between the Son of God and the written Word of God is that both are at once
divine and human, i.e., both truly divine and truly human. Jesus was and is
truly human, as is the Bible, but not merely human.
Rocking with the Bible (special revelation) minus special illumination (NIV) (2)
It was about a year before that time when I
had a completely different experience reading the Bible. The New International
Version had just come out on the market, and my dad was so interested in
getting his children to read it that he offered to pay us fifty cents a chapter
to read the latest modern version of the Bible, the NIV. That sounded good to
me, so every night when I came home, usually around midnight in those days, I
would sit in a rocking chair in my room and try to read a chapter or two
without falling asleep. I remember my mind not being engaged at all in what I
was reading and not recalling the next day much at all about going through the
motions of reading the night before. It was the exact opposite of my two-week
time of reading the entire New Testament word-for-word that was soon to come.
The difference was in the timing.
Reconnected/transformed with clarity/certainty and certitude via special illumination (RSV)
God always has a way of getting our
attention, and with me it was the end of young love, the breakup of a
relationship, my first girlfriend. Before we broke up, I would come home at
night and read the Bible for pay without the one thing that makes all the
difference: the special illumination of the Holy Spirit, as I found out later,
studying theology in graduate school. One of the famous doctrines in the
history of theology, the illumination of the Spirit is the supernatural opening of the heart to go along with the engaging of the mind
when reading Scripture, the result being a certain clarity. Another similar and
related doctrine is the internal testimony, or inner witness, of the Holy
Spirit (Latin: testimonium spiritus sancti internum), which with
the benefit of hindsight I can say is what happened to me when I read the Bible
with new eyes, the second time, for two weeks straight in my room as an
eighteen-year-old. When I knew with certitude that I was looking at eternal
truth, that was the sanctifying work of the Holy Spirit witnessing
to me that the Bible was exactly what Jesus Christ himself always testified to
when it came to the Old Testament, the Hebrew Scripture of his day, which
included all those famous passages that have proven to be such a stumbling
block to the sensibilities of so many modern readers. What I was hearing with
my mind’s ear was, as the Westminster Confession of Faith states, “the Holy
Spirit speaking in Scripture.” A closely related doctrine to what I was
experiencing, as I studied the New Testament intensely, is effectual calling,
or irresistible grace, in which the Holy Spirit applies the redemption Christ
accomplished on the cross. In fact, spending those days long ago in my room
reading every verse of the New Testament, and highlighting the many that kept
speaking directly to me, over and over, was perhaps my own little trip down the
road to Emmaus, as if Christ himself walked along with me expounding Scripture
after Scripture as he did with the believers on that road after the
resurrection (Luke 24:13-35); or maybe it was my own taste of a third heaven
kind of experience in which I was schooled in a special way, which is what
happened to the apostle Paul after his conversion (2 Corinthians 12:2); or
could this have been what John the Baptist meant when he said Jesus would
baptize us with the Holy Spirit and fire (Matthew 3:11)?
Cursed/accursed (Deuteronomy 21:23/Galatians 3:13) (3)
Only one time when I was immersed in the
Bible during those two weeks was I confused about something. The one thing I
couldn’t wrap my head around at that time was the reality of Christ being
cursed. When I read in Galatians 3:13 that “cursed is everyone who hangs upon a
tree,” I just didn’t think I was getting it. How could a good man, the only
perfect man–the greatest person who ever lived–be cursed? At the time, I was so
surprised by the thought that I went to ask my mother, who was the only one
home, what she thought it meant. She didn’t even try to figure it out. She knew
immediately this was a question for my dad and told me to ask him; after all he
was the one working on his seminary doctorate in New Testament at the time. I
don’t remember what happened after that about the confusion, but I later
learned it was simply Jesus taking upon himself my own curse, the curse of my
sin imputed to him so that his righteousness would then be imputed to me, a
major aspect of the theological concept of justification by faith alone, pure
unmerited favor (grace) that it was. So rather than, as with the world’s other
religions, being summed up in the present imperative, “Do this; don’t do that”
(Five Man Electrical Band: “Sign, sign, everywhere a sign/Blockin' out the
scenery, breakin' my mind/Do this, don't do that, can't you read the sign?”),
Christianity is different in that it is actually summed up by Christ’s
next-to-last saying on the cross (John 19:30), "It is finished!" or just by the past participle:
“Done!”
Other objective side of the theological coin (philosophical/historical/scientific rather than existential/experiential) (4)
The main thing I know is that I was changed
from the inside out, transformed from that time forward, never to be the same
again. There was no turning back. Jesus truly made all things new (Revelation
21:5; 2 Corinthians 5:17). Little did I realize then as I do now that the New
Testament I was reading was the last will and testament of God the Father
almighty, maker of heaven and earth, my own inheritance reserved in heaven (I
Peter 1:4), as described by D. James Kennedy, Presbyterian pastor. It
revolutionized my life and made me a different person, all because of the power
of inspired Scripture, what Christianity Today magazine’s
first editor, Carl F.H. Henry, who was recruited by Billy Graham,
called the “complete reliability and authority” of the Bible, in the same sense
as that of the later famous Chicago Statement on Biblical Inerrancy (1978).
From that time on, one aspect of my life has been to fill in the other side of
the coin, the side of objective evidence and whether the truth of Christianity
withstands philosophical, historical, and/or scientific scrutiny. I can
honestly say that throughout all my studies, from the first days of college
through graduate school with three master’s degrees–in linguistics/ESL, biblical
languages/apologetics, and humanities/philosophy–I have never encountered any
evidence that would cause me to reasonably doubt what happened to me at age
eighteen. My studies have done nothing but support the veracity of Scripture
and classic Christian theology. Moreover, as I followed it wherever it led, the
preponderance of the evidence pointed to the “unity of the divine revelation in
nature and Scripture,” as Henry put it in the magazine’s inaugural editorial
more than sixty years ago. Simply put, my own close reading of the Bible
confirmed its “underlying narrative unity,” in the words of one prominent New
Testament scholar, Richard B. Hays. In other words, I’ve never found any good
reason not to be what I’ve always been exposed to: what I call an “incarnation,
crucifixion, and resurrection Christian,” meaning classic Christianity, or mere
Christianity (C.S. Lewis), in which all three of those events are true, each
being grounded in empirical history, uniquely among religions of the world.
In other words, by the end of the two-week defining moment of my life,
devouring every word of the New Testament day after day, I intuitively knew
what I would find out years later through much study and contemplation: The
best explanation of the evidence is the truth of the two greatest propositions
in the history of thought, that God exists and that he raised Jesus from the
dead, as demonstrated by William Lane Craig in his two-step apologetic approach
used in numerous debates with world-renowned skeptics and atheists, and which
means that not only theism is true but that trinitarian theism is.
Sovereign grace (primacy of the divine will)
A major paradigmatic shift in my thinking
came just a few years after my personal encounter with the written Word, around 1978, through a book by J. I. Packer, one of the theological giants of the second
half of the twentieth century. The story involves my first two mentors, my late
father (Robert Couric, editor of the King James 2000 Bible) and my brother (Tom
Couric, same seminary degree as our father). It also features a third mentor
(William Bell of Dallas Baptist University fame). The first thing I remember is
that my brother had a book called The Five Points of Calvinism:
Defined, Defended, Documented (authors David N. Steele and Curtis C.
Thomas). He told me I should read it. Apparently he already had experienced his
own awakening to the priority of God’s sovereignty over our own free will. I
think I read it, but I’m not sure. I can’t remember that book in the specifics.
I do remember sitting around the table at our Everman, Texas, home one day with my dad, brother, and some friends from college. All of a
sudden my dad said something about being a five-point Calvinist, and I was
shocked. Dr. Bell had taught us the four-point view, which denies limited
atonement, that Christ died for believers only. When I objected, my dad simply
said, “You need to read Evangelism and the Sovereignty of God.” So
I took his copy of Packer’s famous book and read it. In a “God said it; that
settles it” moment, I quickly began to see how divine sovereignty and human
freedom or responsibility fit together in historic reformed theology.
Basically, Packer explained that divine sovereignty and human responsibility
are both true, through the use of the concept of antinomy, in which a seeming
contradiction is actually just a paradox, the difference being that a
contradiction can never be true or ever resolved whereas a paradox can or will
be. My brother once explained it in some sermon notes this way: We are one hundred
percent responsible for our sin; God is one hundred percent responsible for our
salvation (counterintuitive asymmetry: human hamartiological determination, or self-determination, and divine soteriological determination). As the British Baptist pastor, Charles Spurgeon, expressed it, both
predestination and free will are true; the Bible teaches both, so they are not
in contradiction. We may not completely understand it or be able to totally
explain it now, but in eternity it coalesces. In a sense, the opposition
between Calvinism and its opposite, Arminianism, is a false dilemma. Instead of
an either-or, it’s a both/and: not either fate alone, which is fatalism (also
known as hyper-calvinism), or libertarian absolute autonomy, which
is humanly impossible, but both divine determinism and human freedom, albeit
limited, known as compatibilism. After reading Packer’s book, I never again had
a problem with that age-old controversy. Dad was right. (5)
Sproul man: more doctrines of grace
With apologies to Sam&Dave, who sang
“Soul Man,” I will always be a “Sproul man” (rhymes with soul), being
heavily indebted intellectually to R.C. Sproul, founder of Ligonier Ministries
and a fourth mentor through his books and tapes, in my paradigmatic shift to reformation theology.
I discovered Sproul the next decade, in 1983, as I was reading a new
book called Loving God by Charles Colson, who mentioned in
passing that he had listened to a series on the holiness of God by one R.C.
Sproul, which series Colson said drove him to his knees. I knew at that moment
I had to find out about this Sproul guy. I soon had the tapes myself, the
beginning of years of influence by Sproul’s theological thinking about, among
many other things, the tension between and compatibility of divine sovereignty
and human freedom or responsibility. For example, Sproul’s widespread influence
was evident in the movie Addiction (1995) directed by Abel Ferrara, starring Christopher Walken, when the character Casanova (Annabella Sciorra) stated, “Now, R.C. Sproul said we're not sinners
because we sin, but we sin because we are sinners. In more accessible terms,
we're not evil because of the evil we do, but we do evil because we are evil.
Yeah. Now what choices do such people have? It's not like we have any options.”
Sproul would surely approve: no option other than a sinless substitute in our
stead, i.e., penal substitutionary atonement.
Richly blessed
In essence, I experienced two paradigmatic
shifts: the first when the Bible showed me that it knew more about me than I
knew about myself, as I was inhaling Scripture for myself (God was breathing it out; I was breathing it in), and the second when
the grandeur or majesty of the Father, the Son, and the Spirit manifested
itself through the goodness, truth, and beauty of the Godhead’s mighty power,
and came to me by a sovereign grace with which I had nothing to do. We choose
him because he first chose us, and we love him because he first loved us. The
more I think about it over the years, the more I think the simple truth is
that, as someone once said, if the first verse of the Bible is true–and there’s
no good reason to think it’s not, nor to doubt the first verse of John or of I
John, both of which I saw with fresh eyes in those days so long ago–then we
shouldn’t have any problem with the rest. In one of those nicest things
ever done for me moments, someone actually once wrote about me that I didn't
really need to be told I was "richly blessed" because I was born that
way. I certainly couldn't disagree with that, somehow intuitively knowing all
along that, by mere grace, I was indeed (twice) born richly blessed.
David R. Couric (couric@dcccd.edu) is retired from Dallas College, Mountain View, with more than 35 years of experience in the higher-education field there, including a decade in the Ink Spot Academic Center for Writing (2011-21); he still works part time as an academic coach (writing tutor) in the Learning Commons.
(1) Didn’t
know it back then, but my brother was going through his own life-defining
moment, what he calls the point of no return in following Jesus, at about the same time as I was, when he was 20, in his first year (1975-76) at Dallas Baptist. I was 18, and my point of no return was a
few months before I started at the college. Incidentally, my younger sister
would have her own defining moment almost exactly one year later, also
a few months before she first became a student at the college; one year apart
in age, both of us had a defining moment at age 18, mine in early 1976 and hers
in 1977.
(2) 1967: fall, redemption
Summer of love (Latin venus and Greek agape)
One Sunday morning in 1967 during the Lord’s supper ordinance, in which I was not participating, it dawned on me suddenly that something was missing, intuitively discerning that I needed to make a profession of faith, with hindsight, to publicly identify with Christ by following him in his obedience to the ordinance of baptism, to be “baptized into Christ” and clothe myself with him, that is, his righteousness (Galatians 3:27). So the best I could in my own 10-year-old way, that’s what I told my mother that week. The next Sunday morning I was in the office of our pastor, Arlen Woody of Carter Park Baptist Church in Fort Worth, Texas, and he led me in a “sinner’s prayer” before baptizing me during the worship service. For me, that marked my conversion and the beginning of the indwelling Spirit of God’s work of supernatural grace in my life.
1969: gratitude, grace, love
In gratitude, by grace, with love…
It was the week of Thanksgiving 1969, and as my 12-year-old self sat on a stage in the gym of the new Everman, TX, junior high school in front of the whole student body, waiting to give the annual Thanksgiving speech my seventh-grade language teacher, Mrs. MacDuffy, had firmly insisted I be the one to do that year no matter how much hemming and hawing I could muster against it, I was anything but relaxed and ready; I was clearly agitated. But the next thing I remember, the school band was playing The Battle Hymn of the Republic (Mine eyes have seen the glory of the coming of the Lord…. His truth is marching on), and suddenly a wave of peace and calm washed over me. I rose and delivered a speech of thanksgiving, which Mrs. MacDuffy also had insisted I write, with uncharacteristic confidence, something I really didn’t think I could do until the moment of meaningful music. I certainly don't remember what I said, but it must have been something about being thankful for home/family, school/friends, and church, or maybe something my teacher suggested. What I had experienced that Thanksgiving week long ago was a powerful demonstration by the indwelling Spirit of the essence of biblical Christianity, the glorious combination of grace and gratitude.
The same Christmas my parents gave us RSV Bibles, 1969, my mother gave us each an individually addressed love letter. She started it by stating that she had decided to write each of her four children his or her own letter as a Christmas gift, telling us how much she loved us. I kept the letter, perhaps the most important I ever received, in that RSV for many years and still have not only the Bible but also that old faded letter, safely filed away. Remember whose you are, she wrote, a child of the king, because you are not your own but were bought with a price (1 Corinthians 6:20). It's hard to overstate the positive impact that simple maternal gesture had on my own sense of origin, nature, identity, purpose, and destiny. Like Isaiah 43:1, her admonition has always reminded me that I’m who he says I am: “But now thus says the LORD who created you, Jacob, and he who formed you, Israel: ‘Do not be afraid, for I have redeemed you. I have called you by your name. You are mine’” (New Heart English Bible). “Who You Say I Am” by Hillsong Worship: I am chosen, not forsaken / I am who You say I am / You are for me, not against me / I am who You say I am. “You Say” by Lauren Daigle: Remind me once again just who I am because I need to know.../ Oh, I believe / Yes, I believe / What You say of me / I believe.*
*When my mother was in the hospital overnight in 1989, in a tale of two letters, I took the opportunity to return the favor and wrote her a love letter in which I directly referred to her 1969 letter to me and even quoted from it to let her know how much it had meant to me for that past 20 years. She said it made her cry, but of course in a good way. It's comforting for me to know that those letters she wrote to us will forever remain rock-solid proof of her love for her children, far beyond anything we ever did to deserve such a blessing.
1972: shaken by doubt
My soul was anxious that night. I could feel my heart rate seemed elevated, and it was keeping me awake at night. As young boys sometimes do when they're desperate, I first reached out to my mother. In the stillness of the night, she wisely shared a Bible verse with me that has never been forgotten: "What time I am afraid, I will trust in thee" (Psalm 56:3). Later on, probably the next night and maybe a few more after that, I remember my father was there, silent, with his hand on my heart until I finally fell asleep, showing me what my heavenly father was like by doing for my body what only God could do for my soul. In some ways, I'm still that boy, (twice) born richly blessed.
(3) 1976: charismatic movement/Jesus people movement (JPM)
Working on a seminary ThD (in New Testament, with dissertation title "The Concept of Jesus as Divine Wisdom in Johannine Literature"), which including the master's took him 11 years, my father was quite proficient at putting current events into theological perspective, including the famous charismatic movement of 45-50 years ago. My questions about the movement were followed by a series of lessons in our youth Sunday school class he taught. Another time I presented him with a book (How to Live Like a King's Kid ) that was all the rage then and asked his opinion. Next thing I knew, he presented me with a legal pad of several pages of notes with his extensive evaluation of the book, which left a lot to be desired theologically, in his estimation.*
*Whatever happened to the Cornerstone? It was a Christian coffeehouse and bookstore near the intersection of Berry and McCart Streets in Fort Worth and had a Friday night worship service for many years, the mid-1970s when I found out about it. It was part of the charismatic and "Jesus people" movements of the late 1960s and early '70s, a genuine awakening across the U.S. even if misguided in some respects. Since the main part of my story of transformation occurred in the mid-'70s, I would consider myself one of those evangelical youth who identified with the Jesus people in the latter stages of or after the movement. Less than a decade later, by the early 1980s, the Cornerstone had morphed into a Christian theater and then church on James Avenue near Southwestern seminary. Before the transition to theater, I was inquisitive and naive enough to visit the Cornerstone office of the minister who preached during the Friday services, whose name I can't recall. He gave me a booklet, perhaps he himself had written, called “How to Receive the Baptism of the Holy Spirit.” I didn't realize at the time that, just as there's only one parousia ("return," or second coming) of Christ, not a second and third a few years of tribulation apart, there's only one Spirit baptism and that Jesus himself has the role of baptizing with the Spirit (and fire), which is at the beginning of the salvation process. So I did what the minister told me to do: go home, read it, and pray. He also told me to return the next Friday night, and at the end of the service he would call me up to the front and go from there. I did as instructed. That night I was standing in the back during the entire service, waiting. He never called me up there. That has always been a cue for me that it was the restraining work of the Spirit graciously protecting me from getting entangled in something from which I wouldn’t be able to extricate myself. It might have been friend Jack Hunt with me when we had a strange encounter with an advocate of baptismal regeneration one Friday night 45 years ago. We were at a restaurant after a Cornerstone meeting, talking about things going on at the time when an older man approached our table, sat down, and issued a challenge. He seemed intent on putting us on the spot, so he asked if we would accept salvation by water baptism if he could present us with an unequivocal verse that said so. It seemed that before we could really respond, or maybe he just read our skepticism, he opened his Bible to that one verse that is so easily taken out of context, much to our surprise: “Baptism now saves you…” (1 Peter 3:21). Although we obviously had seen that verse before, we certainly weren’t ready for it that night. Of course, we still weren’t convinced, but he had managed to make a point, or at least he assumed he had. Wish I had been more prepared and could have shared with him more of the context of that verse, which goes on right after that to say "not the removal of dirt from the body," or anything physical but rather spiritual, and especially in Acts where, for example, in his series on baptism William Lane Craig shows that water baptism and Spirit baptism, the one that saves us, never coincide in Acts, and the order of the two baptisms changes from incident to incident with water baptism as an outward sign of an inward conversion (Spirit baptism), a means of faith, an ordinance, rather than a means of grace, a sacrament.
(4) 2019: WLC
A year before the 2020 pandemic I rediscovered the work of a Christian philosopher I had read some of 35 years earlier when I first started studying for a master’s degree. I now consider William Lane Craig, 72, the greatest living philosopher, not necessarily theologian but pure philosopher. It’s hard to catch him in an error of reasoning when it comes to logic, math, history, and especially any matters pertaining to philosophy, the latter of which reveals his precise and clear thinking. Because of my disagreement with him on soteriological issues going back to when I was first introduced to his books and writing by Professor Jim Parker at Dallas Baptist University (DBU), I had not fully engaged with his thinking until 2019. I then began listening to his famous public debates and other lectures and written material on his website. Within just a few weeks of doing this, I recognized his intellectual weight and now see why he is considered by many to be the world’s greatest apologist, based on his two-step approach of demonstrating the existence of a monotheistic God and then the trinitarian truth of the resurrection of Jesus, sometimes referred to as the first step of natural theology and the second of Christian evidences, or of philosophical (and scientific) argument followed by historical argument. Craig’s the modern-day John Wesley and, as with the originals, easily could have been good friends with the modern-day George Whitefield and greatest recent theologian, the late great R.C. Sproul.
(5)
As Dad used to say, the inscription above the door to heaven proclaims, “Whosoever will may come!” However, once through the door, all who enter there turn and see that inscribed above the door from the inside is, “Chosen before the foundation of the world!” To make Ephesians 1:4 say God chose us because we first chose him is to turn the biblical evidence on its head.* To deny the other side of the coin, or the heavenly inscription from the inside, is to distort the meaning of the words of the hymn "Oh, How I Love Jesus" to "Oh, how Jesus loves me / Because I first loved him" (Frederick Whitfield). In addition, the next verse, 1:5 conclusively states that God's choice of election or predestination is made, not for any reason at all found in us but, for some good reason found in himself alone ("according to the good pleasure of his will").
*The same is demonstrated by Acts 13:48 where it states that "as many as were ordained to eternal life believed," in which no English translation reverses the cause (foreordination) and the effect (faith) because it would do violence to Luke's original Greek text.
The very words of Jesus in John 15:16 (“you did not choose me, but I chose you”) expose what appears to be the fatal flaw in any semipelagian attempt (whether molinism or arminianism, not to mention the more extreme pelagianism, or even the hyperpelagianism of process theology and open theism) to avoid historic calvinism (augustinianism, as opposed to the caricature that devolves into some kind of hypercalvinism, or fatalism), which calvinism nineteenth-century British Baptist Charles Spurgeon, “the Prince of Preachers,” called “just a nickname for biblical Christianity.”
Seems the simplest way to understand God’s will is that the divine will trumps the human will; the divine will has unlimited freedom, and the human will has limited freedom. We are not as free as God, but we are free enough to be wholly responsible for our sin while he is wholly responsible for our salvation. It stands to reason that the creator, the only perfect being, must have a freer will than his less-than-perfect creatures, however free they are, which is just free and independent enough to be fully responsible.
In the tension among wills, one or the others must give way. The divine will is unlimited in freedom, so the angelic and human wills must be somewhat limited in freedom. However, the angelic and human wills are unlimited only in responsibility for sin. So the divine will is limited (to zero) only in responsibility for sin, by the withdrawing of the Spirit. On the other side of the coin, the human will is limited (to zero) in responsibility for salvation, and the divine will is unlimited in responsibility for salvation, by the drawing of the Spirit.
As it is very often the case in these age-old conflicts, the resolution lies in a counterintuitive and paradoxical both/and, a compatible asymmetry as biblical as the day is long: monergism and synergism. The special grace to be saved is monergistic, both necessary and sufficient. The common grace to not sin is synergistic, necessary but not sufficient.
But why at the end of the process would one accede to drawing grace and another resist it? That would mean the grace is necessary but not sufficient. What if the grace is both necessary and sufficient? Then it’s still resistible, and indeed resisted, but not ultimately because grace overcomes the resistance. In other words, grace greater than all my sin wins!
Which sounds more scriptural: We cease resisting and God changes us (wesleyan), or God changes us and we cease resisting (reformed)? We cease resisting because God changes us (reformed),not the other way around (wesleyan).
Bottom-line difference between the two views of free will:
You have to think you acted freely, contrary to your singular old nature, after the Spirit drew you but didn’t actually overcome your resistance, because you just ceased resisting on your own, and before you were changed.
I acted freely, in accordance with my additional new nature, after the Spirit drew me, overcame my resistance, and changed me.*
*Only prefall can angelic and human persons act contrary to their natures; postfall they only act in accordance with their natures.
Sea metaphor:
You have to think that you were dying spiritually, drowning in the vast ocean of sin, and by faith embraced Christ the rescuer of souls, the life preserver, after which he placed you on dry ground.
I was dead spiritually, deep down on the bottom of the vast sea of sin, and only after Christ the rescuer of souls retrieved me and resurrected me by breathing the breath of spiritual life into me did I come alive and by grace through faith embrace him (Ephesians 2:4-5).
Put another way, election is conditional for the wesleyan viewpoint and unconditional for the reformed view. Grace is necessary but not sufficient for the former, and therefore synergistic, but grace is both necessary and sufficient for the latter and therefore monergistic. In other words, wesleyans have a weaker view of grace while the reformed have a stronger view.
For Pelagius, enabling grace was neither necessary nor sufficient for salvation. For Augustine and the reformers, grace was both necessary and sufficient. For all semi-pelagians in between, including Arminians and Molinists, grace is necessary but not sufficient, which means grace is the oxygen necessary but not sufficient for the fire of salvation. For Calvinists, grace is the oxygen and the spark, grace both necessary and sufficient, for the fire of salvation. So are you the spark, or is God the Spirit the spark?
Two views: Grace is necessary but not sufficient such that faith initiates regeneration and justification or grace is necessary and sufficient such that regeneration initiates faith followed by justification.
Wesley and Whitefield both affirmed both divine foreknowledge and foreordination, but neither affirmed divine foreordination so as to remove human responsibility for sin; however, where they differed on foreordination was in respect to salvation. So they parted ways not on hamartiology but on soteriology: Wesley limited the divine will in matters of salvation, and Whitefield limited the human will in the same.
Noncalvinists think the calvinist view calls into question God's love, his omnibenevolence; calvinists see it not as a question of love but simply of justice and mercy. The noncalvinist view leads to the conflation, or confusion, of justice and mercy because it would eventually have to insist that God is obligated to offer mercy to all in the interest of fairness and to avoid injustice. But fairness only has to do with justice, not mercy. No one gets injustice with the just and merciful God with whom we have to do. To think otherwise could call into question God's wisdom, his omnisapience. This confusion of justice and mercy also manifests itself when it comes to common and special grace because there is a grace that is universal and necessary but not sufficient. It's the common grace of general revelation, which prompted the famous reformed expression that general revelation is "sufficient to condemn" but not to save, that is, it's necessary but not sufficient for redemption, only sufficient for judgment. Salvation takes special, or salvific, grace that is both necessary and sufficient.
Molinism’s basic position, probably much like John Wesley’s, has no more to commend itself than classic Calvinism does, and maybe less so, because the mystery that remains with Molinism, related to the origin of evil, is in a sense greater than the mystery that remains in Calvinism and at the heart of Christianity itself. It seems that the two greatest mysteries for Calvinism and Molinism (and Arminianism, for that matter) are that for the former God chooses only some rather than all and that for the latter only some rather than all choose God. The greater mystery is why the some who choose God do so, because ultimately it seems there’s no answer to the question. They just choose God, and the others don’t. On the other hand, to the question of why God chooses some and passes over others, one answer is that he could have sufficient reasons for doing so even if we are not in a position to know them, the same answer often given to the problem of evil and why God allows suffering. Just as in Molinism it may not be feasible for God to create a world in which all freely choose him, thereby resulting in universalism, so in Calvinism there may be good reasons for God not to choose all, even if we never know them (the secret things belong to the Lord). Besides, in light of Jesus’s clear assertion that we did not choose him, but he chose us, it could be that there’s really only that one viable option. In trying to find a via media between Calvinism and Arminianism, in his Molinism, W.L. Craig appears to sacrifice (some of) God’s omnipotence (sovereignty) on the altar of God’s absolute omnibenevolence by assuming that both can’t be absolute just as C.S. Lewis did in his book Miracles when he said God allows for sin by “surrendering a portion of his omnipotence” for the sake of human free will.* Craig thinks that God’s prevenient grace has to be given to all, or else it would call God’s love into question, which is the reason Craig gives in the end for not being a Calvinist: If choosing for salvation is up to God and he could have chosen everyone, then he should have. That’s why Craig takes the position that it has to be up to us, each individually, whether we choose salvation. To be sure, Craig is not talking about choosing the accomplishment of salvation, which everyone agrees only Christ could do, but he means choosing the application of redemption to ourselves. It just seems safer and surer, and more biblical, for the basis of the choice to be in God rather than in us.
*Rather than surrendering a portion of his omnipotent nature, at most he must have just surrendered a portion of his sovereign will, allowing for sin by his permissive will.
Middle knowledge view (conditional election and conditional reprobation):
“It is up to God whether we find ourselves in a world in which we are predestined [to salvation], but it is up to us whether we are predestined [i.e., elected] in the world in which we find ourselves.”
Biblical view (unconditional election as reversal of conditional universal self-reprobation):
It is up to us whether we are reprobated in the world in which we find ourselves; it is up to God whether we find ourselves in a world in which we are elected.
The origins of sin and salvation find their key in the role of the Holy Spirit in withdrawing and drawing in fall and redemption. While creatures angelic and human are fully responsible for their fall into sin, even as the withdrawing of the Holy Spirit allows them to act contrary to their good rather than perfect nature, the creator, who always and only acts according to his nature, is fully responsible for their salvation from that sin by the drawing of the Spirit enabling them to act in accordance with their new nature. Maybe to remain good, (angelic and human) imperfection requires a constant sustaining (divine) perfection. Rather than just free will, perhaps it’s human (and angelic) imperfection that better explains the how of the origin of evil. Similar to the "super-added grace" concept, though good at creation, our not being perfect in the divine sense could possibly explain how we could fall into sin in the first place, the indirect result of a withdrawing* of God’s restraining Spirit in some way (opposite of the direct drawing of the Spirit in salvation). As Sproul puts it, evil’s not good, but it must be good that there is evil, or else there wouldn’t be, because God is sovereign. In other words, creator/sustainer, creation/creatures, fall, redemption, and judgment/re-creation are better than just creator and creation. Ultimately, evil is turned for good because directly or indirectly the divine will, in a primacy of both order and of importance, precedes and takes precedence over the angelic and human wills, as it must be.
*Indebted to Hal Ostrander for this withdrawing idea.
Perhaps in the beginning there was libertarian free will, which was annihilated at both the angelic fall and the human fall, and compatibilist free will was from then the case. That is, before the fall of angelic and human beings, they had libertarian freedom and so had the ability to act contrary to their good, unfallen nature. After the fall, they could act only according to their nature in compatibilist freedom—in the case of angels fallen or unfallen and in the case of humans fallen or redeemed, the latter implying an ability to act according to either of the two (old and new) natures until glorification, at which time redeemed humans, like God and angels now, have the ability to act only according to their new nature because the old has passed away.
# posted by D.R. Couric @ 7:25 AM
