.comment-link {margin-left:.6em;}

Wednesday, February 26, 2020

 

If Dionysus Should Rise Again: A Character Analysis of the Greek God of Wine in Euripides's Tragedy The Bacchae





IF DIONYSUS SHOULD RISE AGAIN: A CHARACTER ANALYSIS OF THE GREEK GOD OF WINE IN EURIPIDES' TRAGEDY THE BACCHAE

                         By Dave Couric


  


                              UTA
                 HUMA 5392: Classical mythology
                      Dr. Charles Chaisson
                           Fall 1993






     "Dionysus is nothing but a two-faced, lowdown wimp of a Greek god who had nothing better to do in mythology than terrorize sweet, innocent old ladies," someone might complain, following a cursory introduction to one of mythology's most famous --- or infamous --- characters, the wine-god sprung from his father Zeus' thigh.[1]  But such a simplistic, though initially understandable, dismissal of Dionysus would betray a failure to grasp the significance of the complexities that surround the one figure in all of Greek mythology that has been exhaustively analyzed to the point of overkill and yet remains as much an enigma as ever, most accurately characterized as simply the "god of paradox."[2]  Dionysus is a legend among mythological characters in the Olympian pantheon, the aristocracy of Greek deities.  Most gods are at times portrayed inconsistently.  Zeus, e.g., is both the arbiter of morality and first to transgress his own ethical laws.  But compared to the other gods, Dionysus practically defies description altogether.  He seems to be the one who is most susceptible to extremes, generally associated with such diverse areas as life, death, the afterlife, and drama.
     Euripides' posthumously award-winning Bacchae (which refers to the women who follow Dionysus), produced in 406 B.C. Athens, has the new god Dionysus claiming divinity in his hometown of Thebes, which has rejected him.  Dionysus, whose name is derived from Zeus (Dios), punishes this reaction by driving insane those who will not follow him, including not only the women of Thebes but also his cousin and the young king, Pentheus.  Though he is called a liar by Pentheus, Dionysus through a sheer act of superior power ("possessed by Dionysus!" the chorus sings at one point, 120[3]) establishes his lordship by making Pentheus a lunatic.  By internal rather than external force Dionysus achieves his status as god of a new mystery religion, one that is initially accepted by some, resisted by others, but finally accepted by all in the end, even as punishment with violence unto death for Pentheus is meted out in the name of justice.
     Dionysus might be repulsive to the average reader today for a number of reasons, but it seems that he is paradoxical on two levels.  First, in relation to the other gods, especially Apollo, Dionysus forms an antithesis.  Second, in relation to himself Dionysus is antithetical.  In relation to the others in the pantheon, Dionysus could be considered the "black sheep of the family."  He is not one of the 11 "charter members" of the pantheon.  In fact, he is not always the 12th member, being interchanged as such with Hestia.  So, in the evolution of myth, Dionysus seems to be on the fringe as far as the pantheon goes.  Yet the one known also as Bacchus (Roman) has been scrutinized more than any other.  This scrutiny and analysis of Dionysus is often done in conjunction with the one god who seems to be almost a polar opposite, Apollo.  As the god of healing and a representative of what is considered the progressive generation of younger gods, Apollo has traditionally been held up as the ideal: the god of order, rationality, and the like.  On the other hand, Dionysus has been contrasted with Apollo.  Dionysus is supposed to be the god of violence, chaos, and irrationality because he is always associated with the cult practiced in his name in which his followers work themselves up into a drunken, orgiastic frenzy in order to be in union with the god.  And, at least in the mythological versions, the ritual culminated with the eating of raw flesh (omophagia) and the drinking of blood, after a sacrificial animal had been dismembered by participants (sparagmos).  This experience was supposed to prepare the people for life after death since Dionysus is considered the god of afterlife.  Strangely enough, there is a line or two in the Bacchae that would lead one to think that maybe Apollo is not the opposite extreme of Dionysus after all.  Coryphaeus, the chorus leader, responds to Teiresias' theodicy concerning Dionysus with these words: "Apollo would approve your words. / Wisely you honor Bromius [Dionysus]: a great god" (325-30).  So the polar opposites view may be an oversimplification.  Nietzsche is probably most responsible for the modern contrasting of these two Greek gods in the study of mythology.  He apparently saw Apollo and Dionysus as representing two strands of Greek thought and of course wrote about it in his famous book, The Birth of Tragedy.  However, it seems that the situation with Dionysus is more complicated still.  On another level the god is paradoxical within himself, apart from any consideration of Apollo or any other of the gods.  It is not that he is always negative while Apollo, e.g., is positive.  Indeed, Dionysus is both the god of happiness and life on the one hand and madness and death on the other.  On a positive note, in a passage reminiscent of the biblical idea of wine given by God to "gladden the heart of man," Dionysus is said by the chorus to give "the simple gift of wine, / the gladness of the grape. . . .to rich and poor."  He also is described in the same context as "generous of good" (420).  Within himself, then, Dionysus seems to oscillate between two poles of positive and negative.  Perhaps this is why he has always been so difficult to define.  His own words best sum up this paradoxical situation when Dionysus describes himself thusly: "Dionysus, son of Zeus, consummate god, / most terrible, and yet most gentle, to mankind" (860).  At first he appears as kind, sweet-smiling, and soft-spoken.  Then, without warning, he can become a hard, holy terror, inflicting violence on his victims, or those who cross him.  Even the chorus, which has apparently accepted Dionysus without being forced to, acknowledges that the god is "hard, but. . .sweet" (65-70).  This "light" versus "dark" side theme is common in the study of Dionysus.[4]  Just as the dark side of human nature is constantly appealed to in order to make sense out of numerous anomalies of evil, so might Dionysus be considered to represent the dark side of Greek deities.  Again, while he might be considered the dark side of the gods as a whole, he still seems to have a light and dark side within himself.  In this sense he could be considered the personification of both good and evil, in the classic dualistic way.  Since the Greeks had no devil in their theology, one way to explain evil is through an eternal dualism in which good and evil are supposed to be equally ultimate.  The point is that Dionysus cannot simply be compared or contrasted to the other gods in order to understand him.  In a more complex way he must also be examined as an individual and considered with all the ambiguities and perplexities that are wrapped up within himself.[5]
     Some issues never die, and the very existence of deity is one that folks in Euripides' time must have wrestled with, just as people do today, since the tragedian has Cadmus make the comment that Pentheus, for the sake of family honor (time), ought to at least act like he believes Dionysus is a god even if he really is not:  "Even if this Dionysus is no god, / as you assert, persuade yourself that he is," Cadmus advises Pentheus.  "The fiction is a noble one, for Semele will seem / to be the mother of a god, and this confers / no small distinction [time[6]] on our family" (335). In a pragmatic move Cadmus appeals to tradition in an effort to get Pentheus to see the futility of an obstinate refusal to go along with religious practice.  But Pentheus will have nothing to do with this "madness."  In the same context it seems that the reality of gods in general is not being challenged but simply the reality of a "new god on the block" who has not yet proven himself.  For Cadmus points out that Pentheus' cousin died a violent death after insulting Artemis --- to which Pentheus offers no rebuttal, suggesting his unspoken acceptance of Artemis.  Perhaps Euripides, himself a student of the sophists, is illustrating the variety and degrees of skepticism in his own day by attempting to demythologize mythology,[7]  contrasting the pragmatic view of Cadmus, who seems to imply himself that Dionysus may not be more than human, with that of his grandson, Pentheus, who wants to treat the new religion in town as a forgery.  But since it is practically impossible to figure out what the people off stage thought about the play, the character of Dionysus as presented in the Bacchae is the only proper object of inquiry.  In a similar vein it would be difficult to know whether Euripides' theology was typical of the times, or whether he was taking advantage of the paradoxical, questioning nature of tragedy and writing so as not to reflect the prevailing view of the gods, or religion.  Presumably, though, the Bacchae is the best source for information about what Dionysus was like in the Greek mind, regardless of whether the majority equated myth with history or not.[8]
     Since information about Dionysus is limited to the tragedy by Euripides, at least as far as Dionysus being a central character, there is only so much to go on in attempting an analysis.  Normally in literature, one would look to the thought, speech, and actions of a character for information, along with commentary provided by the author.  In the nature of the case, no commentary is provided by the author of the Bacchae because the tragedy is a drama, a play.  However, there are contained in the drama comments by other characters about Dionysus that should be considered.  Also excluded in such a genre as tragedy are the thoughts of characters.  Therefore, the analyst is left mainly with what the character says and does as key to who he is.  In that sense, then, analysis involves an attempt to get at the character's ontology (nature) through linguistic (dialogue) and ethical (behavior) means, without recourse to epistemology (thought). 
     The decisions characters make reveal something about them.  For example, in a general sense the decision of Dionysus to return to his homeland and assert his identity shows that he is fiercely proud.  For however long the desire or need to have the worship of the city of Thebes had been building up, it seems that there came a time when Dionysus decided to make himself known for who he claimed to be: a god, son of Zeus.  He clearly states that his religion is established "that I might be revealed on earth for what I am: / a god" (20).  And then, he announces: "Like it or not, this city must learn its lesson" (40).  Moreover, along with the pride in his heritage there is an attitude of revenge in Dionysus as he seeks to exonerate the name of his late mother, Semele.  She has been wronged in that her reputation was varnished when her sisters and the townswomen suspected her of lying about the identity of Dionysus' father in order to avoid embarrassment over the pregnancy.  Dionysus came back to set right the wrong inflicted on his mother, who was killed by Zeus' thunderbolts because he believed that Semele had denied him.  So Dionysus comes to Thebes in a proud vengeance, ready to take on any who stand in his way.  In fact, his vengeance turns to contempt and hatred by the end when Dionysus declares, "For Pentheus I care nothing" (635-40).  In addition to wanting respect for his mother, he wants a lot of respect by the people for himself.  In fact, this overbearing pride may be the major character trait of Dionysus, although he obviously is a difficult character to pin one main characteristic on.  For example, true to his unusual nature, he seems at once both anxious and serene, open and secretive, adventurous and timid, noisy and quiet, reasonable and hotheaded, straightforward and underhanded --- not to mention ambitious, aggressive, assertive, confident, visionary, and biased.  Perhaps Dionysus displays these latter characteristics most explicitly when, speaking in the prologue of Pentheus' rebellion, he says: "[Pentheus] now revolts against divinity, in me; / thrusts me from his offerings; forgets my name / in his prayers.  Therefore I shall prove to him / and every man in Thebes that I am god indeed" (45-50).
     The appearance of Dionysus is important to understanding his character, if for no other reason than to accentuate his ironic essence.  He appears from the start as effeminate, a physical characteristic that seems to aptly describe him throughout the play, except for the few times that he is compared to a bull with horns and all.  The chorus mentions, e.g., "the bull-horned god" with "serpents on his head" (100).  The effeminate appearance of Dionysus is especially emphasized as Pentheus describes him from hearsay as "one of those charlatan magicians, / with long yellow curls smelling of perfumes, / with flushed cheeks and the spells of Aphrodite / in his eyes.  His days and nights he spends / with women and girls" (235).  Then when he does see Dionysus for the first time, Pentheus confirms the rumors: "So, / you are attractive, stranger, at least to women" (455).  Whether this physical femininity corresponds to any psychological dimension of Dionysus is difficult to say.  For a god who is as tough as Dionysus is, it does indeed seem ironic that he would appear in effeminate form.  However, considering his track record for being and doing the unexpected, perhaps this is fitting after all.  Also, the fact that his followers are generally women must have something to do with the way Dionysus looks in mythology.  This may be part of Euripides' purpose in the tragedy, i.e., to lend some sympathy to the plight of women in Greek society.[9]  From another angle Dionysus might be viewed as downright deceptive in his appearance.  Other gods seem to often manifest themselves in all their glory while Dionysus comes "incognito, / disguised as a man" (5).  As if he knows his birthplace will not worship him as he is, he decides to force the residents to do it.  As Pentheus is starting to succumb to Dionysus' influence, the deception has clearly gone beyond appearance.  "You are an old hand at cunning," Pentheus remarks.  To which Dionysus replies, "Dionysus taught me everything I know" (825).
     Dionysus is difficult to categorize as to type of character.  On one hand, he seems to be the protagonist moving against Pentheus, the antagonist.  On the other, Pentheus is the one who is being victimized by Dionysus, in which case Pentheus would be the protagonist.  The latter option may be best simply because the protagonist is usually a dynamic, round character that undergoes change or growth, which certainly does not sound like Dionysus, who seems to be on the static side.  Since he is in a sense a god-man, son of a mortal mother, it is a different situation in classifying Dionysus as to type than it is for a human character such as Pentheus.  In addition, it seems that Pentheus is the protagonist in the sense that Euripides draws on the audience's sympathies in such a way that the human character is the easiest to identify with.  Perhaps this is a way for Euripides to make a statement against his own culture in general and the Dionysiac element in particular.
     Throughout the Bacchae Dionysus calmly says over and over that in effect his name will be honored in Thebes as elsewhere.  He says this at the beginning in announcing his reason for being there, and he says it all the way through to the end when he gives the honor of his name as the reason all of the catastrophes occurred in the first place.  For example, Teiresias expresses this aspect of Dionysus as a jealous god when he tells Cadmus that "[Dionysus] desires his honor from all mankind. / He wants no one excluded from his worship" (205-10).  Only once, it seems, does Dionysus waver on that point when at the very end he seems to pass the buck to Zeus, who ordained it all anyway.  But then, as Cadmus and Agave are saying their farewells to each other, Dionysus once again makes his case: "I was terribly blasphemed, / my name dishonored in Thebes" (1375).  In any event Dionysus' mentioning that he will be honored serves to indicate that he considers himself worthy of respect --- and will see that it is given him, or else.
     If there is one thing that is for sure with Dionysus, it is that his actions back up his words.  When he says something is going to happen, it inexorably does.  He carries through with every promise or threat, and there is no stopping him.  Whether positive or negative, Dionysus keeps his word.  In fact, his words themselves seem to possess psychological power as Pentheus attests, before locking Dionysus up in prison and later falling victim to the subtle trap the combative god has set: "You wrestle well --- when it comes to words" (490), Pentheus admits.  Later, he adds, "It is hopeless to wrestle with this man. / Nothing on earth will make him hold his tongue" (800).  One time, though, that Dionysus seems to go back on his word is when he tells Pentheus that Pentheus is not insane ("Your mind was once unsound, but now you think / as sane men do," 945-50) after Dionysus had clearly commanded him to be made insane ("distract his wits; / bewilder him with madness," 850).  Of course, at that point it would not have really mattered what Dionysus told Pentheus since it is impossible to reason with a crazy man.  According to his own admission, what Dionysus does best is give the gift of wine, "his chiefest glory" (650-55).  But what he does with Pentheus is an altogether different story.  Throughout the play Dionysus never fights Pentheus directly.  He is more subtle than that.  It is as if Dionysus will not give Pentheus the benefit of seeing a direct display of divine power.  Instead, Pentheus is exposed to one indirect assault after another, culminating in dismemberment and death, which again is not directly inflicted by Dionysus but rather by his maenads.
     The commentary of other characters, such as the chorus, can shed some light on Dionysus' character.  Since the chorus is made up of his followers, it is to be expected that they would only have nice things to say about their leader.  Naturally, Pentheus is the character that says the most about Dionysus.  From Pentheus' perspective the god is no god at all --- simply a charlatan out to corrupt the women of the city through a wild religious festival.  Pentheus has nothing but contempt and scorn to heap upon Dionysus, from ridiculing his appearance to threatening the stranger with violent death.  Two other characters, Cadmus and Teiresias, take practically the opposite view.  Knowing the power of the gods, they take no chances and decide to support this new religious movement in town.  They even advise Pentheus to come along with them, but he refuses.
     There is no escaping the fact that Dionysus is associated with violence.  Therefore, his character is called into question since gods and goddesses are usually conceived as embodying those qualities of the best and most moral human beings.  If gods are supposed to represent the ideal, then Dionysus might once again be better conceived as the devil among the gods.  It certainly seems that Zeus has given Dionysus free reign in Thebes, and no one ever went to hell in a more devilish way than the gruesome, flesh-ripping sendoff given to Pentheus.  Actually, this fate should come as no surprise since the chorus had already revealed that Dionysus "delights in the raw flesh" (140), an observation sure to draw the characteristic "primitive and obscene" charge from naysayers.  Of course, the larger question is whether Pentheus deserved what he got and by extension what that reveals about Dionysus' nature.
     If there is a Greek god of one attribute, it is certainly Dionysus.  There is only one thing, it seems throughout the Bacchae, on the mind of this one who has been forever slighted: justice.  "All justice, no mercy" sums up Dionysus well.  Contrast, e.g., the biblical "Father, forgive them; they know not what they do" with the Dionysiac version: "You do not know the limits of your strength.  You do not know what you do.  You do not know who you are" (505).  The drive to see punishment exacted consumes Dionysus and permeates the entire drama.  Since holiness seems to imply perfect righteousness, the concept of justice is included when, e.g., the chorus praises Dionysus as holy: they speak of the "holy body of god," the "holy dance of god," and the "holy wand of god" (75-80).  Later, Dionysus even tells Pentheus, "My hair is holy. / My curls belong to god" (490-95).  Dionysus is presented, or presents himself, as a holy, just god.  But the question arises as to whether he is just or unjust.  Dionysus is certainly not merciful, which would not be the same as unjust, since mercy is nonjustice rather than injustice.  So there is no use in appealing to any kind of repentance in order to avert the sentence of Dionysus, who is no god of the second chance.  At the brink of death Pentheus utters a semblance of repentance when he admits to his mother that "I have done wrong" (1120).  Justice allows no more than one chance --- only mercy goes beyond to the second or more chances.  Cadmus is not any help in figuring out whether Pentheus deserves what he got or whether Dionysus is just.  Cadmus calls Pentheus "a noble victim" of Agave but then says that Dionysus did it all "justly --- too, too justly" (1245-50).  Of course, Dionysus had made it clear what he thinks about the justice of Pentheus' fate: "you are worthy of your fate," the god tells Pentheus, who by that time is dressed to kill, ready for sacrifice.  Then, in what would be understatement to describe as sarcastic, Dionysus promises kleos to Pentheus as a result of his upcoming "extraordinary experience" (970-75).  What Dionysus seems to have is a sense of his own arbitrary divine justice, with which no corresponding human responsibility can legitimately be connected.  In an age of equality and justice such as today's, one might be tempted to entertain the possibility of a resurrection of just such a god of sheer justice as Dionysus.  "Dionysus has been so drastically uprooted from his original Greek habitat and transplanted to modern regions where blood is more plentiful than wine that he might not survive," Henrichs states --- then asks rhetorically, "Can Dionysus be saved?"[10]  Let's hope and pray that this god stays in the graveyard of history for a long time to come.  

             
  
BIBLIOGRAPHY

Euripides. The Bacchae in Greek Tragedies Volume 3. D. Grene and      R. Lattimore, eds. University of Chicago, 1959.
Euripides. A.S. Way, trans. Loeb series III. London: Heinemann, 1962.
Goldhill, S. "The Great Dionysia and Civic Ideology." Nothing to      Do with Dionysos? J. Winkler and F. Zeitlin, eds. Princeton,   1990. 97-129.
Henrichs, A. "Loss of Self, Suffering, Violence: The Modern View      of Dionysus from Nietzsche to Girard." Harvard Studies in      Classical Philology 88 (1984) 205-40.
Lewis, C.S. Miracles. Macmillan, 1947/60.
Segal, C. Dionysiac Poetics and Euripides' Bacchae. Princeton,   1982.
________. "The Menace of Dionysus: Sex Roles and Reversals in      Euripides' Bacchae." Women in the Ancient World. J.    Peradotto and J. Sullivan, eds. State University of New    York, 1984. 195-212.
Skow, J. "Dionysus at 50 and More Woe." Time 142/22 (November 22,      1993) 82.
Winnington-Ingram, R. Euripides and Dionysus. Cambridge, 1948.




    [1]Though he sort of disappeared from the scene of history centuries ago, Dionysus is enough of a household name even today to be included as a sketch, "The Mid-Life Crisis of Dionysus," in Garrison Keillor's American Radio Company show and a chapter in his new book, The Book of Guys.  Keillor has Dionysus' wife, Ariadne, telling her husband he is washed up at 50 years of age as a result of his excessive drinking.  "The dancing and drinking and whooping and wahooing is what makes the wheat grow, babes.  That's what gives us the corn crop," Dionysus says.  J. Skow, "Dionysus at 50 and More Woe," Time 142/22 (November 22, 1993) 82.
    [2]This summation of Dionysus is from W. Otto, Dionysus: Myth and Cult (Bloomington, 1965) 121, cited by A. Henrichs, "Loss of Self, Suffering, Violence: The Modern View of Dionysus from Nietzsche to Girard," HSCP 88 (1984) 234.
    [3]Hereafter, quotes from the Bacchae will be followed in text by number of approximate line(s), taken from Greek Tragedies Volume 3, D. Grene and R. Lattimore, eds. (University of Chicago, 1959).
    [4]Henrichs, "Loss of Self," traces the history of this development and shows that while the renaissance period followed the Greeks and re-emphasized Dionysus' relation to life, the modern view has basically been an obsession with the death and violence associated with the god.
    [5]S. Goldhill, "The Great Dionysia and Civic Ideology," Nothing to Do with Dionysus? J. Winkler and F. Zeitlin, eds. (Princeton, 1990) examines the paradoxical nature of Dionysus in relation to the Athens festival and finds a comparison between the god of tension or conflict and both the questioning and honoring of the polis through tragedy and pre-play ceremonies, respectively.  By showing the great contrast in attitudes presented in the theater before and during the dramas, a political-social interplay between "norm and transgression," Goldhill concludes that the festival in Dionysus' name indeed has much to do with him.  The significance of the plays go beyond the common idea of reversal or inversion of roles to what apparently amounts to an ultimate symbolic ethical revolution --- a challenge to the norms and transgressions themselves.
    [6]Euripides, A.S. Way, trans. Loeb series III (London: Heinemann, 1962) 28.
    [7]R. Winnington-Ingram, Euripides and Dionysus (Cambridge, 1948) viii, comes to the conclusion "that the Bacchae is in some sort a play against Dionysus. . . .[a] drama permeated with a spirit of protest."
    [8]C.S. Lewis, Miracles (Macmillan, 1947/60) 133-34, proposes a unique hypothesis of myth and history on an analogy with the classic Christian doctrine of the incarnation.  He sees an evolution of truth as embodied first in myth (e.g., the Old Testament) and later in history (New Testament) --- without ever ceasing to be myth even when it becomes fact, just as God never ceased to be God when he became man in the incarnation.  Defined thusly, myth is "a real though unfocused gleam of divine truth falling on human imagination."  However, Lewis seems to be speaking of a Judeo-Christian myth and history, not Greek.
    [9]Segal, "The Menace of Dionysus: Sex Roles and Reversals in Euripides' Bacchae," Women in the Ancient, J. Peradotto and J. Sullivan, eds. (State University of New York, 1984), makes the point that Euripides collapses the categories of male and female as seen, e.g., in the struggle between the "macho" Pentheus and the "feminine" Dionysus or in the charge undergone by Agave from mother to warrior, from culture to nature.  Euripides seems to blur the line of distinction between the sexes in order to suggest that there are some identical characteristics shared by the two genders.  But rather than positing some identical characteristics, it seems more plausible to suggest that male and female characteristics are all complementary.  By definition a male has no female characteristics and vice versa; however, all male characteristics might be seen as complementing all female and vice versa.  To maintain real yet complementary differences between the sexes seems to be the most balanced approach.  Segal also discusses this aspect of Dionysus collapsing categories in Dionysiac Poetics and Euripides' Bacchae (Princeton, 1982) 234, where he says that "Dionysus operates as the principle that destroys differences."  The author goes on to point out "the multiple inversions and contradictions of Dionysus" in the Bacchae, 266.
    [10]" Loss of Self," 234.



Comments: Post a Comment



<< Home

This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?