.comment-link {margin-left:.6em;}

Monday, February 24, 2020

 

When Homosexuality Isn't a Choice*

In 1974 while I was in high school and working part-time in a downtown Fort Worth parking garage, something startling happened. One night I was sitting in the office getting ready to close up when the other employee on duty casually informed me that he was a homosexual. He was a fairly new employee -- so I didn't know him very well -- but this confession shocked me nevertheless. I had never given much thought to the subject in my short, "sheltered" life. I was in for an education, to say the least. This was the first time I had ever personally known a homosexual, at least that I am aware of. Although he hardly knew me, this young man chose to confide intimate details of his life to me in the next few moments, for reasons known only to himself. In the process, he became my friend, albeit for only a short time.

Contextual
Homosexuality has become so prominent a social issue in the last few years that -- except for the continuing negative impact of the AIDS disease -- history might look at the past decade and call it the "Gay Nineties" just as was done a hundred years ago for an entirely different reason. As a topic of investigation, homosexuality is indeed timely. As a human action, it is practically timeless. That homosexuality has been in existence since time immemorial is virtually unarguable. And no one is likely to suggest that homosexual activity will suddenly stop someday while the world carries on as it always has. What attitudes have been taken historically (and what attitude should be taken today) toward the subject, however, is debated considerably -- especially at this time in history.
Presently, there is considerable disagreement concerning private and public attitudes about the subject of homosexuality. It is such an emotional issue that most people have strong feelings about it one way or the other. On both sides, emotion tends to get in the way of rational consideration of the matter. Taking a rational look at an emotional issue proves to be a difficult thing to do for many of those involved in working out the social or political ramifications of the issue of homosexuality. Like it or not, society is faced with resolving a conflict that has presented itself so forcibly that it cannot be ignored indefinitely. The problem is homosexuality in a culture that is diverse, with various views on almost any subject. Especially as of late, homosexuality has risen to the forefront of social issues. It is one of the two or three most hotly debated issues in politics, next only perhaps to abortion. Like abortion, the issue of homosexuality is not going to go away on its own. It must be dealt with.

The man I worked with at the parking garage was only a few years older than I was, and I could immediately sense that he wanted to do some serious talking that night about his situation. At first I was caught off-guard by this sudden revelation since he neither appeared in any way as a stereotypical homosexual nor said or did anything at work to suggest such previously. He simply blurted out all of a sudden that he had this secret. Without much response from me, he continued to explain his predicament. One of the things that has remained in my memory is that he said he was a Christian. This was perhaps the most unexpected information I learned in the hour or so in which he related his story to me in the office that night. He said he was a Christian and that he knew what he did as a homosexual was not right. He also said he knew that "the power of Christ" was sufficient for him to stop engaging in homosexual activity. I did not have much advice to offer him, but I knew that he was right according to everything I had been taught in my own traditional background. So I simply agreed with him on that point.

Conceptual
Rather than the existence of homosexuality, the nature and origin of homosexuality are the most controversial points in the debate. Most of the debate in the past seems to have centered on the latter. If asked, most people will give their opinions about homosexuality on the basis of the "nature-nurture" distinction. That is, they will say that if homosexuality is innate, or biological or hereditary, then there is no way to change the behavior and it is therefore perfectly acceptable. Or, if it is learned, or social or environmental, then there is and perhaps should be a way to change. These two options are popularly presented as mutually exclusive so that either one or the other cause alone is possible. For the average individual in society and judging from the way the subject is treated in the mainstream media, the origin of homosexuality is the key to ending the debate. But an examination of the arguments by scholars seems to reveal that the nature of homosexuality is more important an area to consider in looking for a solution to one of society's most volatile issues.

For example, both Yale historian John Boswell[1] and University of Illinois philosopher Richard Mohr[2] place little emphasis on the heredity-environment part of the debate. Instead, they emphasize the question of what homosexuality is, or what it means to want or have sexual relations with members of one's own gender. These scholars are more concerned with the nature or definition of homosexuality rather than the origin or cause of it. They want to discuss whether the issue is primarily about homosexual persons or homosexual acts -- and the relation between the two.

Terminology is important to consider in discussing homosexuality. The word gay has been suggested as a replacement for the adjective homosexual. Boswell, for example, defines the latter in a broader way than he does the former. The concept of "homosexuality" for Boswell entails any "same-sex eroticism" while "gay" is limited to people who are "conscious" of their homosexual identity.[3] Intention, then, is the distinction that Boswell uses to define gay as opposed to homosexual. Mohr, however, simply chooses to use the term gay as normative from the start, which is not at all uncommon in the literature.[4] The point at which terminology seems to be most significant is when the term lesbian is introduced. For some reason, there is a term strictly for a female homosexual in common English usage, but apparently there is not for a male homosexual. Gay certainly refers to both male and female, so it is broader than lesbian in that sense. Homosexual refers to both male and female, so that makes it a synonym of sorts with gay. Why then, one wonders, has the media adopted the use of the phrase "gays and lesbians" rather than just including both under the rubric "gays"? Is not "gays and lesbians" a redundancy? To be consistent there should be a term referring only to male homosexuals, a true counterpart to lesbian. In terms of the debate, it seems simpler to use less politicized words such as homosexuality for the concept and homosexual as a noun for the person or as an adjective to describe the act. In addition, the primary concern of the debate seems to be centered on homosexual acts (homosexuality) rather than persons (homosexuals), on behavior or conduct rather than preference or status. For example, the military controversy notwithstanding, both sides of the homosexuality debate seem to be interested in whether or not to allow certain people to do certain things, not just be a certain way.
Another operative word in the debate about homosexuality is tolerance. This is the word that is most closely related to the theme of the entire issue. However, there is another word that is almost as important. It is approval. The distinction, or lack thereof, between these two terms is pivotal in the ongoing debate. Generally, there is an understanding in the public mind about the difference between approving of something like homosexuality and tolerating it. On the one hand is the intent to normalize homosexuality in a call to transform culture through not only tolerance but approval. And on the other hand is the attempt to eliminate homosexuality altogether through both disapproval and intolerance. Although the distinction between approval and tolerance is not often made explicit, implicitly the difference is apparent to the more than casual observer. The mainstream media, for example, do not explicitly speak of approval but only tolerance regarding the issue of homosexuality. That is, the media -- for obvious reasons -- do not use the word approval as a synonym for tolerance in communicating to the public about the subject. Whether the same meaning is implied, regardless of which word is used in this debate, remains to be seen -- and is certainly a matter of debate itself.

The question remains: how should individuals and society think about this subject, and what should that society do in regard to its relation to the individuals that constitute the category of homosexuality? Because of fierce disagreement about the origin and even the nature of homosexuality, the problem is not simple, but complex. Even if conflict concerning the origin and nature of homosexuality cannot be resolved, perhaps a consensus on the ethics of homosexuality and what to do about it can be achieved.

After expressing his general religious convictions, my co-worker began to tell me how difficult it was to act on his belief that as a Christian he had the power to overcome what he described as homosexual addiction. Another thing that was impressed on me that night was the reason he gave that it was so difficult to stop living the way he had been for so long. Without going into great detail, he said that as a small child he was taught by adult males to participate in homosexual practices. He said that as a result, the behavior had become a very strong habit that he could hardly break. It was the early development of this kind of activity that he emphasized as the most difficult barrier to breaking the habit, which he continually insisted was his desire to do. In fact, he told me that in his effort to change he had pursued several dating relationships with girls, only to return to his former ways as time went on. He even said he had a girlfriend at that particular time when he was talking to me, but he was afraid it would not last.

Critical
The arguments about the topic of homosexuality can be divided into at least two broad categories: general and specific. The general arguments usually concern the philosophical debate about the ethics and morality of homosexuality. The more specific arguments involve the theological perspective. John Boswell's historical book Christianity, Social Tolerance, and Homosexuality seems to represent the latter while Richard D. Mohr's philosophical treatise Gays/Justice more of the former.

Boswell's thesis is that Christianity may be the occasion for but not the cause of intolerance toward homosexuality as just one example of social intolerance; therefore, homosexuality should be tolerated if not accepted by Christians. Mohr's thesis is that justice demands that society, ethics, and law treat homosexuality in such a way as to not discriminate in any sense of the word. Besides their homosexuality, one thing Boswell and Mohr have in common is that both would probably say that their respective theses have remained largely unfulfilled.

Another thing the two authors have in common is that they both made the critical distinction between approval and tolerance explicit early on in their books, Boswell on the first page of the first chapter and Mohr even earlier, in the table of contents at the end of the first chapter. Unfortunately, neither seemed to maintain the distinction throughout the rest of his book.

The title of the seventh and last section of Mohr's first chapter is a question: "How would society at large be changed if homosexual acts were decriminalized and gays socially tolerated or even accepted?" (emphasis added). Here, by including the word even in the question, Mohr is clearly making the distinction that is so important to the debate about homosexuality. But nowhere else in his book is this distinction, that there are really two levels of response to the issue of homosexuality, discussed. This is unfortunate because by including the distinction in the table of contents, the author gives the impression that the difference between the two concepts is real. By the end of the book, if not much sooner, the reader gets the distinct impression that Mohr is not as interested in society reaching a level of tolerance of homosexuality as he is in acceptance or approval. The question for Mohr is: would he accept tolerance, short of acceptance?

Boswell, to his credit, discusses the distinction in some depth, albeit in the second footnote of the book alone. Most people paying attention to the ongoing debate about homosexuality in this culture would probably assume there are only two positions to take. Either one goes beyond tolerance to approval of homosexuality, or else one is intolerant and of course disapproving. But Boswell is careful to show that he is not committing the "either-or" fallacy. He allows for a third alternative so that the two sides as popularly presented are not mutually exclusive. One is either tolerant or intolerant and approving or disapproving, but the four do not necessarily go together symmetrically as might at first be expected. The "synthesis" takes tolerance and disapproval and puts them together to form a third position. A person can disapprove of homosexuality while still remaining tolerant of it, Boswell asserts: "Non-acceptance of disapproved behavior or traits does not of course necessarily constitute intolerance. . . ."[5] This is an important step in the right direction for resolving or easing the tension between polarized groups in the debate. The problem is that Boswell does not seem to continue in the same direction after making such a crucial initial point. For example, Boswell basically claims that Christianity has been used as a rationalization for intolerance. He says that Christianity is not the origin of intolerance, but he does not allow that Christianity may be the reason for disapproval. Moreover, as some of his peers -- such as University of Virginia historian Robert L. Wilken -- have suggested, there appears to be an underlying plea for acceptance throughout Boswell's work. In other words, despite his best efforts to neither "praise nor blame" as an historian, he cannot seem to hide the fact that he has a huge stake in the outcome of his project, a condition described by Wilken as "advocacy scholarship" and "scholarship by speculation."[6]

For example, Wilken questions Boswell's "assumptions that control his discussion of the historical evidence." Wilken says that "it is anachronistic in dealing with classical antiquity and Christian history" for Boswell to use the word gay in the way he defined it as "persons who are conscious of erotic preference for their own gender." The reason that it is an anachronism, Wilken states, is that "preference for persons of one's own gender is not characteristic of those who engaged in homosexual acts in antiquity." So Boswell's meaning of the term gay is "foreign to antiquity," Wilken charges. Thus, "Boswell not only misrepresents the sources, and hence the attitudes of those who wrote them and the societies in which they lived, he creates historical realities that are self-contradictory, and hence not historical." If Wilken is right, then Boswell's subtitle ("Gay People in Western Europe from the Beginning of the Christian Era to the Fourteenth Century") is at odds with the main thrust of the book itself. Wilken:

After arguing that the categories of "homosexual" and "heterosexual" did not intrude on the consciousness of the ancients (pp. 58-59), he goes on to speak of "gay literature" in antiquity or of social tolerance of "gayness" (p. 73). Yet in the same paragraph he says that Roman society assumed that adult males would be interested in sexual relations with both sexes. If that is so, one cannot speak of "gay" as a class of persons defined by "preference." On the following page he says that there were no prejudices directed "to homosexual relations as a class." The reason is obvious: the ancients did not think there was a class of people with sexual "preference" for the same sex. . . . The notion that there is a "class" of people defined by sexual preference is a very recent idea that has no basis in western tradition.[7]

The problem with Boswell and Mohr is the same as the problem with the debate on homosexuality in general: neither of the two sides of tolerance and intolerance seem to admit a tertium quid in the dispute. Even a casual observer would come away with the notion that while the side for tolerance may say "tolerance," what those in favor of homosexuality mean is approval. Where is the distinction between tolerance and approval made explicit in any of the general information available to the common person about the subject of homosexuality? When was the last time anyone published for general public consumption, reported in the mainstream media for example, such a statement that argued specifically for tolerance as opposed to approval -- or to go beyond tolerance to approval? The latter especially seems to be virtually non-existent: no one seems to come right out and say the public should approve of homosexuality even though that is clearly what many people mean when they engage in the debate. In other words, it is a given in much of the treatment of the debate that the distinction between approval and tolerance is a distinction without much of a difference. This idea of going beyond tolerance to approval is related to the ethical concepts, descriptive versus normative or prescriptive. To argue for approval beyond tolerance is to attempt to normalize homosexuality, to prescribe it. That means it becomes normal behavior, i.e., good in an ethical sense. Descriptive behavior (morality) merely describes what is the case while normative or prescriptive (ethics) states what should be the case. Those who favor tolerance short of approval, and even those who are intolerant, are against normalizing homosexuality, a movement that would make it entirely acceptable culturally. This may or may not happen in the future, but the point is that the purposes of all sides in the debate need to be made explicit whereas they are often left implicit in which case it is left up to the observer to try and discern ambiguous intentions.

Those who seek to normalize homosexuality seem to violate a basic premise that they start with. The premise is that values should not be imposed on anyone. However, to normalize homosexuality would be to impose that value -- that homosexuality is good or right -- on the dominant culture, which has traditionally opposed homosexuality in general. By forcing the dominant culture, through law or simply societal pressure, to change its value concerning something as fundamental as sexual attitudes, the pro-homosexuality side of the debate is doing the very thing it criticizes: the imposition of values. It seems clear that freedom must be limited by something outside the individual. Otherwise, one individual's freedom is going to conflict with another's right. If individuals are really free to choose their own values, what is to stop an individual from choosing values that transcend that given individual and apply to the whole group? The individual who is not in favor of homosexuality being normalized is certainly free to choose that value. But the other individual who wishes to normalize homosexuality is also free to choose that value. The question is, how will such a stalemate ever end? The ethical position that individuals should be free to follow "their own lights," as Boswell and Mohr put it, simply does not work out in the end. It sounds good at first. But when carried through to its logical conclusion, there is no resolution -- only final conflict. One man's light is another's darkness. Minorities can always claim victim status and cite wrongful imposition of values by the majority, but eventually the situation may be reversed. The old majority might become the new minority claiming imposition of values, too. But the values would be different this time around. Does that mean both sets of values are right? If so, both sides could have saved a lot of time and trouble by simply agreeing to live with both sets of values in the first place, which would actually seem impossible because it is contradictory. This is the conundrum from which ethics tries to extricate itself. It appears that values will be imposed one way or another.

My new friend had one other bit of information to share with me that night. He told me that another employee at the parking garage where we worked was a homosexual also. I was warned to watch out for him because "he'd like to take you home with him." Of course, I had never suspected any such thing and was surprised at that, too. So that night I found out I was working with two homosexuals and never would have known it, had one of them not decided to tell me his story. I was so young and naive that it startled me at first because I did not know what to expect or how to react when first informed of such circumstances in the life of a fellow employee. As it turned out, I mostly just listened -- and learned from that experience.

Constructive
The solution to the problem of homosexuality, as it is for many other similar ethical issues, is equal toleration but not equal validity. All positions may be equally tolerated without contradiction or absurdity though not all positions can be given equal validity without the contradiction of relativism. This is similar to the distinction between approval and tolerance. If everyone were convinced to approve of homosexuality today, it would require far more than what is usually meant by tolerance alone. People's worldviews would have to be changed radically. In fact, each person would essentially have to adopt a worldview very much like everyone else in order to see eye-to-eye on such things as homosexuality. But to just tolerate homosexuality without changing fundamental facets of one's worldview would not require such a radical move. In the same way, to give equal validity to diametrically opposed positions involves attempting to reconcile a contradiction. All views cannot be equal. The view that all ideas are equal entails that the idea that all views are equal is better than the idea that all views are not equal. If the idea that all views are equal is better than the idea that all views are not equal, then all views are not equal after all. So each side of the homosexuality debate should tolerate the other because each side has the right to be wrong even though neither side thinks it is wrong.

Toleration is an absolute rather than relative principle. By definition, the concept implies a standard from which to allow variation. Equal validity is a relative principle that is ultimately incoherent. Equal toleration is an absolute principle and therefore can be universalized -- and put into practice objectively.

The genuine tertium quid, then, in the homosexuality debate falls squarely between approval on one side and intolerance on the other. It is not approval, but it is tolerance -- or toleration, to use a less emotive word. The third alternative in the dispute is the age-old distinction between the person and the act: toleration of the human being while at the same time disapproval of particular human action. Something -- or someone -- can be understood without agreeing to it. This position retains the important emphasis on the dignity of a person qua person. By virtue of being human, a person -- even a Hitler or a Stalin -- has dignity and deserves some kind of basic respect as such, which is what toleration is all about.

Much debate has centered on the biblical passages either referring to homosexuality or not, depending on who is doing the interpreting -- Boswell for instance. Usually the Old Testament is cited, particularly the Leviticus text, in the ongoing theological debate. The New Testament is then cited, usually Pauline passages in Romans, I Corinthians, and I Timothy. However, sometimes Christ himself is mentioned with the observation that he never said anything about homosexuality. While the Bible records no comments by Christ on that subject, the classic narrative of "the woman caught in adultery" (John 7:53-8:11) might indeed be a parallel case in point for the issue of homosexuality. Both sexual offenses were punishable by death, according to Jewish law.

In the famous New Testament passage, some Jews bring a woman to Jesus. They say she was caught in the very act of adultery, to which they await Jesus' response. To their persistent questions about stoning the woman to death, Jesus replies with the famous line, "Let him who is without sin cast the first stone." One by one, they depart leaving Jesus alone with the woman. He refuses to condemn her ("Neither do I condemn you"). The pericope ends with the most important line of all. Jesus tells the woman, "Go and sin no more" (emphasis added). This is the distinction between approval and tolerance. If Jesus had simply said, "Go," and left it at that, it could possibly be construed that he was going beyond tolerance to approval. But by adding "sin no more," he stopped short of approval. In fact, his parting remark clearly entails disapproval of the act yet toleration of the person -- or perhaps an affirmation of personhood. He forgave the woman -- and yet explicitly prohibited her from continuing the behavior.

If this traditional text is taken as representative of the spirit of the scriptures as a whole toward sexual offenses such as adultery and -- analogously -- homosexuality, then it seems disingenuous to argue that the Bible sanctions homosexuality. Rather, the biblical conclusion about adultery appears to coincide with disapproval of homosexuality and toleration of homosexuals. So the distinction between approval and tolerance leads to another important distinction, between homosexuality and homosexuals.

As I have reflected on the subject of homosexuality since that experience many years ago and especially lately as it has become prominent in the news, I cannot help but notice the lack of any information through the media about the more specific topic of child recruitment by adult homosexuals. Rarely if ever have I seen or heard any of the numerous news or talk shows addressing this apparently taboo concern even in passing -- yet it is the main point that a young homosexual emphasized in relating his personal story to me. Was my friend's experience indicative of widespread practice? Or, was this an isolated case that I happened to be acquainted with all these years?

Conclusion
Maybe William Bennett is correct when he makes the point that divorce should be the stronger focus of society's attention these days because it causes more harm than homosexuality.[8] Perhaps while the culture wages a battle on the homosexuality front, there is a bigger war raging on another front, that of the proliferation of divorce. If so, then the disproportionate amount of time spent and energy expended in the homosexuality debate would be a costly error in the long run. Hence the historical tendency to consider homosexuality a far greater evil than adultery or divorce may legitimately be criticized.

To frame the issue of homosexuality as a debate simply between love and hate, victims and bigots, the tolerant and the intolerant -- for and against -- is not only unfair, it is a deceptive false dichotomy. If the truth be known, the vast, silent majority would probably say "a pox on both your houses."

I do not think my homosexual friend that night knew about many arguments for or against homosexuality, or at least he didn't mention anything that specific aside from the "power of Christ" to change. He simply lamented the fact that, for him at first, being a homosexual was not a choice. He was too young at the time to make up his own mind. If memory serves me correctly, it seems that a year or so later, after we both had gone on to work somewhere else, I got word through someone at the parking garage that he had a steady girlfriend and was planning to get married. That was the last I heard of him.

[1]Christianity, Social Tolerance, and Homosexuality (Chicago, 1980).
[2]Gays/Justice: A Study of Ethics, Society, and Law (Columbia, 1988).
[3]Boswell, 44.
[4]But does that mean heterosexuals are sad? asks Keith Thomas, New York Review of Books (December 4, 1980): 26. He also points out that Boswell defends using the word nongay as the opposite of gay while in the same chapter saying that to divide the world into Christian and non-Christian is "pointless and silly" to most of the world.
[5]Boswell, 3-4.
[6]Robert L. Wilken, affidavit for Denver (County), Colorado, district court case Evans v. Romer (state of Colorado; October 7, 1993): 6. Coincidentally, Wilken earned his Ph.D. in the history of Christianity from the University of Chicago, which published Boswell's book. Moreover, Boswell teaches at Yale, which recently published a book by Wilken on another subject. In a review of Boswell's new book, Same-Sex Unions, Wilken, "Procrustean marriage beds," Commonweal (September 9, 1994): 25-26, says that "the book has a contemporary social agenda. . . . This is a book on a mission, scholarship at the service of social reform, historical learning yoked to a cause, a tract in the cultural wars. . ." David Wright, senior lecturer in ecclesiastical history at the University of Edinburgh, Scotland, concludes his review, "Do You Take This Man. . .," National Review (August 29, 1994): 60, of Same Sex Unions this way: "One cannot but admire [Boswell's] immense resourcefulness and glittering intuitions, and lament the fallacious sophistry in whose service they are enlisted." Wright had earlier called Christianity, Social Tolerance, and Homosexuality "influential but highly misleading on the early church" in his article "Homosexuality," Encyclopedia of Early Christianity, 436. Peter Linehan, Times Literary Supplement (January 23, 1981): 73, writes in a review of Boswell's Christianity, "This is the leaden interpretation of the obsessive inquisitor rather than of the dispassionate inquirer." Patrick Henry's way of describing the same book in a review in the journal Church History 51 (December 1982): 448, is representative of the more positive assessment. He says Boswell's book is "revisionist history governed by patient determination to listen to the sources, not by ideological agenda or methodological obsession."
[7]Wilken, 7-8.
[8]John Leo, "On Society: A new values vocabulary," U.S. News & World Report (October 3, 1994): 22. D.S. Bailey, in his classic Homosexuality and the Christian Western Tradition [1955] (Archon, 1975): 165ff, makes precisely the same point.

*Written for a UTA doctoral humanities class in the mid 1990s.

Comments: Post a Comment



<< Home

This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?