Monday, August 24, 2020
Time
Dave Couric
PHIL 5392-501 (Dr. Reeder)
Short Essay 1: Time
September 28, 1993
"Time keeps on
slippin', slippin' into the future" went an old song on the radio years
ago. The inexorable march of time has
been the subject of considerable philosophical reflection yet seemingly without
much in the way of substantial results.
The nature of time is mysterious indeed. Phenomenologically speaking,
though, time is the key to metaphysical dualism and the Cartesian legacy since
all experience happens through time. The
concept of time has been expanded, it seems, to include all of human experience
so that not only (material) extension but (formal) thought also is contained
within the parameters of time.
Moreover, the conception
of experience itself seems to have been universalized, now crossing over the
border from the aposteriori to the apriori, from "matters of fact"
(MOF) to "relations of ideas" (ROI).
Although apriori has traditionally meant "from beginning,"
i.e., before or without experience, the phenomenological re-conception in the
context of temporality gives the indication that experience is somehow more
broadly considered in that universals as well as particulars are
experienced. For example, everyone has
the experience of apprehending that two plus two is four even though this
"fact" is actually in the realm of ROI. Perhaps this is an example of a
"synthetic apriori" statement, like time and space themselves are, in
the Kantian sense. While the Humean
empiricists restrict all experience to the external, phenomenologists
apparently recognize the legitimacy of experience being from the inside
out. Perhaps it is a move from a
strictly empirical experience to a rational, or even mystical in the later-Heideggerian
sense, experience. ROI are no longer
considered atemporal ("not in time") but omnitemporal ("through
all time"). That is, the temporal
becomes the eternal. Thus there has been
a phenomenological shift in ROI, from outside to inside of time, so that
Heidegger's horizon of time limits the extent to which human beings can
go. Time, in phenomenology, includes
both realms of MOF and ROI, extension and nonextension, empirical and rational,
inductive and deductive, material and formal.
Matters of fact belong to
the physical realm, i.e., nature. This has traditionally been understood as the
arena of space and time. MOF are
spatio-temporal, empirical, and extended.
Sense perception is the way MOF are known. Some empirical scientists, following the
Humean model, would insist that MOF are all there is in the universe. This would be a type of physicalism that denies
existence to anything not contained in space and time. The "materialist
hypothesis" at least implies that everything is "atoms in the
void." On this view, there is no
true mental, much less spiritual, existence.
Taken to its logical conclusion, this position (some forms of
materialism) ends up in phenomenalism. Most forms of materialism end up in
phenomenalism because they follow generally Hume's thought. He did not accept the "double
existence" postulate of both objects and perceptions. Therefore, his system necessarily involves
the perception of perception, or perceiving perceptions rather than objects. This seems to lead to an infinite regress impossibility
of perceiving perceptions of perceptions and so on, ad infinitum.
Since everything that is
extended takes up space, MOF must necessarily be associated with space. And since time is often referred to as a
fourth dimension, it too seems to necessarily be connected with MOF. The question raised in phenomenology, however,
is whether time, rather than being limited to MOF, could actually encompass
more than MOF.
Relations of ideas belong
to the rational realm of nonextension, or thought. Thought has no shape, no dimensions. It is not in space but in the intellect, so
not extended. Since ROI are nonphysical,
they have traditionally been viewed as existing outside of or transcending
space and time, not limited by the physical laws of science. ROI are involved
in the scientific methodology of Descartes, who posited the duality of thought
and extension. Although he called the
mind and body "almost a single entity" in the sixth meditation
synopsis, Descartes’s legacy has been the problem of a metaphysical dualism
regarding the connection between thought and extension, or nonextension and
extension, the mental and physical. An
extreme idealism would have only mental reality to the exclusion of the
physical, just as materialism does in the opposite direction.
The idea of phenomenology seems to include as a key component the relationship of time to ROI and how humans experience such. If all human experience is in or through time, then time cannot be limited to MOF but must also take in ROI. So although ROI are certainly not in space, they are nevertheless experienced through time. In this way, time crosses over from its traditional domain with space in MOF to the nonextended realm of ROI. Hence ROI is no longer considered atemporal, but omnitemporal. Time is, practically speaking, eternity since there is nothing outside it, nothing that escapes its influence. While space remains traditionally "temporal," so to speak, time is not so much temporal as it is eternal. Consequently, the number two, e.g., is not in space, nor is it atemporal. Rather, it is in time, in the omnitemporal sense.
The possibility of this reconstruction of spacetime apparently hinges on the relationship of the two and whether they can be separated. It may be that the proper conception of physics is the key to the relationship of space and time, although the distinction needs to be kept between phenomenological time, which is descriptive, and theoretical spacetime, which is not. If the classical view of physics is correct, then time and space are absolute, fixed, objective realities, not influenced by anything external, according to Newton. But if Einstein is right, then time and space are relative, based on the activity of light. The new physics may be a factor in how time and space are related, something Descartes, to say the least, would have found interesting. Even within the contemporary conception of physics, the conflicting reports between the macro and micro levels could be an area of relevancy to time and its ambiguities, i.e., in the ontological indeterminacy versus epistemological uncertainty debate over the Heisenberg principle. The philosophy of space and time is therefore an important topic for current study by philosophers. Views on time, e.g., "tensed" (traditional) and "tenseless," should be given careful and critical evaluation in order to better grasp such a crucial concept. The question has been raised in philosophical theology, concerning the concept of divine eternity, as to whether God should be considered a timeless ("divine timelessness") rather than temporal (or omnitemporal) being since, analogously, divine omnipresence does not usually imply extension in but transcendence of space (even when immanence is taken into account).
Whereas mysterious time
was once linked only with space in the domain of MOF, it has now been
phenomenologically conceived as "extending" beyond the borders of the
physical universe, reaching into the immaterial realm of ROI, and providing the
horizon or context for all of reality, both external and internal, empirical
and rational, so that no aspect of human experience is left untouched. Time therefore becomes the great equalizer,
the one inescapable factor with which both the subject and object are brought
into contact. Time, structuring reality
at the most fundamental level, is experienced by all.
