Saturday, December 04, 2021
Three Modern Abortion Myths
Three Modern
Abortion Myths as a Case for Abolition
I was 15 on January 22, 1973, when the notorious Roe v. Wade was ruled by the supreme court (overturned June 24, 2022), so there’s no memory for me of that monumental unconstitutional miscarriage of justice, I'm now ashamed to say, not because I had thought of it and ignored it but because I was blissfully unaware of such weighty matters.
Now, over 50 years and 62.5 million slain human lives later, according to the pro-abortion Guttmacher Institute, the count goes on; it's such an atrocity that I can hardly believe we've sat around for half a century and let this keep happening day after gruesome day in which the systematic slaughter of innocents in their mothers' wombs continues apace, one life snuffed out at a time by suctioning and dismemberment. This modern-day holocaust is why since making the mistake of not taking abortion into account my first time to vote in a national election in 1976 at age 19, I've never agonized about whom to vote for in any subsequent election: straight ticket every time.
My first memory of even knowing about
abortion was in college at Dallas Baptist a few years after the landmark court decision. I was asked to
write an editorial for the Chieftain newspaper on a topic of my choice.
Just so happened I had noticed a Chick tract someone left lying around on
campus and picked it up and read it with interest and profit; it was on
abortion, written by a famous cartoonist, Jack Chick. It was clear to me right
then how wrong abortion had to be, and I wrote the editorial heavily relying on
Chick’s points, probably way too much because I hadn’t really learned how to do
research and cite information correctly. It did elicit a positive response soon
after from a famous professor on campus, Dr. Bell, who as I was sitting in his
class remarked that he was glad to see that the Chieftain had started
publishing some good editorials.
That was the beginning of a long process
resulting many years later in some simple conclusions about this polarizing
issue and some of the major myths associated with it, such as that always being
for the children is the right thing to do, except in the case of abortion,
that denying
that a fetus is a person justifies the aborting of a human life, and that minimizing
another’s choices to zero via abortion is somehow still prochoice.
Myth 1: Being for the children is
always and everywhere the right thing to do, except in the case of abortion (underdog devictimization).
Proponents of abortion at the same
time often claim, ironically, to be advocates of children in general. But when
it comes to abortion, there seems to be a major blind spot.
While comparing homosexual rights with the
two major rights movements in history, black civil rights and women’s rights,
is a false analogy because no Dred Scott decision exists for homosexuals,
comparing legalized abortion with the two main rights movements is a true
analogy because Roe v. Wade is the Dred Scott decision of all aborted children
since that time.
In Roe, the court ruled that a particular class of people, in this case based on age (and/or size), was subhuman just as another class was ruled partly human, based on race, more than a hundred years earlier. Classism based on the age of the human life in the womb is ageism just as racism is classism of an analogous sort.
Either way, an entire class of human
beings was or is discriminated against. One group was enslaved, and the other
is executed. In reference to Patrick Henry’s immortal words, while probably
only some of the slaves would have agreed a century and a half ago with “Give
me liberty or give me death,” all of the aborted children, given the chance,
would surely cry, “Give me life rather than death.”
Black
civil rights, women's rights, homosexual rights, and aborted children’s
rights:
1.
Dred Scott > civil rights (blacks were denied rights of personhood, voting)
2.
Women's suffrage > women's rights (women were denied rights, the right to
vote, for example)
3.
? > homosexual rights (homosexuals were never denied personhood or voting
rights, never had to sit in the back of the bus)
4. Roe > children’s rights (prebirth children were denied rights of personhood)
The political argument for
homosexual rights, then, even though often portrayed as such, is not analogous
to the case for black civil rights or women's rights. In fact, the argument
against homosexual rights can be used against abortion rights also since it
turns out that abortion is analogous to both the civil rights and women's
rights movements.
In addition, abortion is the modern
analogue to ancient child sacrifice: Among its most ardent proponents, abortion
is invalidated when the practitioners have “even so much as expressed any grief.”
In other words, some proponents embarrass and make fools of themselves by
publicly boasting of their abortions, making abortion the modern-day analogue
to the ancient child sacrifice to a false god, Molech.[i]
Rather
than stand with the Democrats on their platform’s stance that emphasizes the
mother over the child (“We will continue to oppose—and seek to overturn—federal
and state laws and policies that impede a woman’s access to abortion, including
by repealing the Hyde Amendment [,which prohibits taxpayer funding of
abortion]”), it makes more sense to stand with Republicans and their platform’s
stance emphasizing the child (“We oppose the use of public funds to perform or
promote abortion or to fund organizations, like Planned Parenthood, so long as
they provide or refer for elective abortions or sell fetal body parts rather
than provide healthcare…. Accordingly, we assert the sanctity of human life and
affirm that the unborn child has a fundamental right to life which cannot be
infringed”).[ii]
Abortion (life) is one of the five issues
that are points of disagreement between the Democrat party’s 2020 platform on
the one hand and the Republican 2020 convention resolution and 2016 platform
and recent Southern Baptist Convention resolutions on the other. The other four
points of disagreement between the so-called progressive party and the party of
Lincoln, which aligns with the SBC, are sexual deviancy and sex education
(marriage and family) and capital punishment and global warming.[iii]
Abby
Johnson, a former Planned Parenthood clinic director, described abortion in
detail at the 2020 Republican National Convention: “…for me, abortion is real.
I know what it sounds like; I know what abortion smells like. Did you know that
abortion even had a smell?”[iv]
After all, in the case of abortion the child/baby is totally innocent and not responsible 100 percent of the time while the mother is innocent and not responsible only approximately 1 percent of the time due to rape, incestuous or otherwise.*
Being for the children, the underdog, is almost always and everywhere the right thing to do, especially in the heinous case of legalized abortion.
Myth 2: Denying that a fetus is a person justifies the abortion of a human life (person dehumanization or, more specifically, depersonalization).
What do you do if you think you have
to justify abortion (and euthanasia) by any means necessary? Figure out a way
to arbitrarily use what you think science says about consciousness to
dehumanize the victims by denying the personhood of some human beings! Then
come up with a proposal for a constitutional amendment on personhood that would
allow for both abortion and euthanasia. Such a proposal is no myth but
unfortunate reality.[v]
It seems that for this to work,
there would have to be widespread agreement on what consciousness is and how it
is explained, and apparently that is not the case currently in science or
philosophy.
Besides, even if consciousness could
be defined and explained to common agreement, the qualifiers “current” and
“permanent” would erect an insurmountable obstacle to societal acceptance. Who
would be the arbiter of current consciousness and permanent loss of it? In
addition, the proposed amendment bites off more than it can chew. It not only
is an argument for abortion on the basis of nonpersonhood; it is also an
argument for euthanasia on the basis of nonpersonhood, so in effect such an
amendment would apply to more than it explicitly addresses. Also, logically personhood seems to precede
humanity: At either end of life, a dead human being is a dead person. This logical escape clause, the abortionist's only conceptual defense, is fallacious because in principle there could be persons who are not human beings but no human being is not also a person.
If you illustrated it with a Venn diagram, you would make “person” the bigger circle and put “human being” inside as a smaller circle because the concept of personhood entails the logical possibility of divine and/or angelic beings as well as human beings, which means personhood is actually the broader concept and therefore a necessary but not sufficient condition for being human. Reversing that is to change the meaning of personhood at the risk of introducing the fallacy of equivocation.
Without
changing the meaning of person, the argument would be something like this:
1.
If a human fetus* is not a person, then it is not a human being.
2.
A human fetus is a human being.
3. Therefore, a human fetus is a person.
*The argument would equally apply to human embryo or zygote (all the way back to conception, or fertilization).
Denying the personhood of human
beings of any age or size on any basis is a form of dehumanization, analogous
to the dehumanization a century and a half ago of slaves and of American
Indians by denying their personhood, making them subhuman, hence the three-fifths
clause of the constitution and the “trail of tears.”[vi]
The logical approach would be a
human-life amendment clarifying that the 14th amendment guaranteeing rights for
all persons as citizens includes everyone from scientific (biological) beginning
to end.
Meet the new intellectual sleight of
hand–same as the old. Just as defenders of slavery back then dehumanized slaves
by denying their personhood on the basis of race, defenders of abortion today
dehumanize embryos and fetuses by denying they are persons, based on age and/or
size: “If I thought I was killing a person, I wouldn’t do abortions. A fetus is
not a person; it’s a human entity” (Alabama Abortionist Willie Parker).[vii]
In other words, as usual the
gatekeepers have it exactly backward logically, desiring that the truth be that
they can have a human being in existence without at the same time also
having/being a person. Truth is, they can have a person without a human being
(God or angel, for example) but not a human being without a person. Personhood
is a broader category than humanity, not narrower. So just as there can be
oxygen without fire but no fire without oxygen, there can be no human being at
any age or size who is not also a person. It’s just not logical, regardless of
what Justice Harry Blackmun, the author of the majority opinion, thought in
Roe, for example.
Jonathan
Wells on abortion: “…shortly before the U.S. Supreme Court’s decision in Roe v.
Wade, legal scholar Cyril Means Jr. published a letter in the New York Times
using Haeckel to justify abortion…. But Haeckel’s drawing was known to
misrepresent the truth even in his own lifetime…. Just as a developing fruit
fly is never anything but a fruit fly, so a developing human being is never
anything but a human being. To deny this is to deny the evidence — which is
equivalent to denying empirical science.”[viii]
Apparently for some, abortion is
“the right to dismember an unborn human being who can feel pain.” According to
Nik Hoot, “I knew that I was supposed to be an aborted baby and it failed. It
makes me angry because I would never want for that to happen to any kid… I just
look at myself as a miracle.”[ix]
Just as slavery is analogous to abortion
when it comes to choice, so does the analogy ring true with similar arguments for
both concerning property, personhood, dehumanization, and victimization, as
Frederick Douglass, for example, in his autobiography argued even during the
time of legalized slavery in this country. In addition, the past analogue to abortion opponents who go too far to the point of violence against abortionists is John Brown's crusade against slavery, which in Douglass's estimation went too far. In other words, Douglass agreed with his friend Brown on the ends (freeing slaves) but not on the violent means (killing slaveowners). Douglass's attitude about Brown's ends and means should be a model for abortion opponents today.
Denying that a human being is a person, based on age and size, does not justify the taking of a human life by abortion.
Myth 3: Minimizing another’s choices to zero via abortion is "prochoice" (choice minimization).
Applying a maximal-choice test to the prochoice position shows it fails; applying the test to the prolife position, it passes. The way to show the self-refuting nature of legalized abortion is to put it to the test in terms of either choices or individuals.
Against
abortion (emphasis on choices):
1.
Prochoice on any issue should maximize the number of choices.
2.
Prochoice on abortion fails to maximize choices because it minimizes to zero
future choices of aborted individuals.
3.
Therefore, prolife is maximally prochoice because it minimizes choices the
least.*
*Prochoice is minimally prochoice because it fails to maximize the number of choices.
Against
abortion (emphasis on choices), slightly expanded:
1.
A prochoice position on any issue should maximize the number of free choices,
present and future.
2.
The prochoice position on abortion fails to maximize the number of free choices
because it necessarily minimizes to zero the future free choices of individuals
aborted.
3. The prolife position maximizes the number of free choices of as many individuals as possible without minimizing any choices arbitrarily.
Against
abortion (emphasis on individuals):
1.
A prochoice position on any issue necessarily includes individuals making their
own choices in life. A prochoice position on abortion necessarily excludes the
individuals aborted, who would otherwise have gone on to make their own choices
in life.
2.
Therefore, the so-called prochoice position on abortion is logically incoherent
and immoral because it allows for only a select few, namely, those not the
victims of abortion, to make their own choices in life while arbitrarily
excluding innocent victims of abortion with no voice in the matter.
3. And therefore, the prolife position is the real prochoice position on abortion because the anti-abortion position is the only one that allows for as many individuals as possible to make their own choices in life without arbitrarily taking away the choices of others.
Against
slavery (by analogy):
1.
A true prochoice position on any issue necessarily includes all individuals
making their own choices in life. A prochoice (proslavery) position on slavery
necessarily excludes the individuals enslaved, who would otherwise make their
own choices in life.
2.
Therefore, the proslavery position on slavery is fundamentally incoherent and
immoral because it allows for only a select few, namely, those not the victims
of race or class discrimination, to make their own choices in life while
automatically excluding innocent victims of race or class discrimination.
3. And therefore, the antislavery position is the real profreedom position on slavery because the abolitionist position, by choosing freedom for all, is the only one that allows for all individuals to make their own choices in life without eliminating the present and future choices of a select some.
Seven [Canada, China, Netherlands, North Korea, Singapore, the United States and Vietnam] out of 198 nations in the world allow elective abortions after 20 weeks of pregnancy. “This one seemed a bit surprising, so we looked into it. And it turned out, it’s backed by data....We award the elusive Geppetto Checkmark when a factoid surprisingly turns out to be true, as in this case,” admits The Washington Post.[x] The unrealistic demand for choice can lead to other absurdities, such as when one state, New York, recently went to this extreme: “In other words, abortion will be available to women essentially on demand up to the point of birth.”[xi]
As should be apparent, arguments for
abortion based on choice are very much analogous to arguments for slavery a
century and half ago. Just as today’s abortion proponents sometimes say, “Don’t
like abortion? Don’t get one!” so could slavery proponents back then just as
easily say, “Don’t like slavery? Don’t own one!” As Luke Story, longtime director of the Mountain View College writing center, put it one day in casual conversation: The difference between prochoice and prolife comes down to one critical suffix, or infix, the difference between selfishness and selflessness.
Minimizing someone’s choices to zero, by abortion, is not a prochoice act.
Trying to separate one kind of child
from another–postbirth from prebirth–or trying to separate a person from a
human seems to fall into the same old self-defeating trap as championing
choice, but only selectively and arbitrarily. Whether abortion is discussed in terms of women's rights or choices, it seems that, while we can't grant rights or choices to women of the past, there's no good reason we can't grant them to all women, both of the present and of the future, and not just to those who fortuitously escape the abortionist's scalpel. Leave it to two great presidents
in two different centuries to succinctly and presciently point out the obvious,
that the emperor had no clothes, whether in the case of slavery or abortion,
and show why anyone and everyone should be modern-day abortion abolitionists.
Abraham Lincoln: “Although volume upon volume is written to prove slavery a
very good thing, we never hear of the man who wishes to take the good of it, by
being a slave himself!” Ronald Reagan: “I’ve noticed that everybody who is for
abortion has already been born.”
[i] https://coldcasechristianity.com/writings/quick-shot-the-bible-condones-genocide/?utm_source=feedburner&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=Feed%3A+ColdCaseChristianity+%28Cold+Case+Christianity%29
[ii] 2016 platforms.
[iii] How Democrats' platform
compares with SBC resolutions
How Republicans’ stances compare with SBC resolutions
[v] https://www.skeptic.com/reading_room/how-science-might-inform-personhood-abortion-rights/?utm_source=eSkeptic&utm_campaign=c29a15e257-EMAIL_CAMPAIGN_2019_02_12_08_57&utm_medium=email&utm_term=0_8c0a740eb4-c29a15e257-73366101&mc_cid=c29a15e257&mc_eid=61a30acfec
[vii] https://www.nationalreview.com/2019/01/march-for-life-stands-up-for-science/?utm_source=Sailthru&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=NR%20Daily%20Monday%20through%20Friday%202019-01-14&utm_term=NRDaily-Smart
[ix] https://evolutionnews.org/2020/09/at-what-point-in-its-development-can-a-human-being-feel-pain/?pardot-link=button
[x] https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/fact-checker/wp/2017/10/09/is-the-united-states-one-of-seven-countries-that-allow-elective-abortions-after-20-weeks-of-pregnancy/?noredirect=on&utm_term=.d8bdcfca7661
[xi] https://www.nationalreview.com/corner/new-york-state-senate-passes-expansive-abortion-bill/
*https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation/2019/05/24/rape-and-incest-account-few-abortions-so-why-all-attention/1211175001/ (D. James Kennedy: "It is interesting that abortions for incest, rape, and the life of the mother constitute less than 2% of the total number of abortions in this country, and yet they constitute more than 98% of the rhetoric of the pro-abortionists.") Parents who put themselves above their already growing but not yet born child are selfish; those who do the opposite are selfless. A suffix, like a baby, changes everything.
Back to main page: Memorable Memories: One Son's Memoirs of Life in the Robert Adams Couric (1929-2011) Family
